Highland Shores Children’s Aid Society v. N.P., 2013 ONCJ 151
Opinion
WARNING The court hearing this matter directs that the following notice should be attached to the file: This is a case under
Part III of the Child and Family Services Act and is subject to one or more of subsections 48(7), 45(8) and 45(9) of the Act. These subsections and subsection 85(3) of the Child and Family Services Act , which deals with the consequences of failure to comply, read as follows: 45.—
(7) Order excluding media representatives or prohibiting publication. — The court may make an order, . . . (
c) prohibiting the publication of a report of the hearing or a specified part of the hearing, where the court is of the opinion that . . . publication of the report, . . ., would cause emotional harm to a child who is a witness at or a participant in the hearing or is the subject of the proceeding.
(8) Prohibition: identifying child. — No person shall publish or make public information that has the effect of identifying a child who is a witness at or a participant in a hearing or the subject of a proceeding, or the child's parent or foster parent or a member of the child's family.
(9) Idem: order re adult. — The court may make an order prohibiting the publication of information that has the effect of identifying a person charged with an offence under this Part. . . . 85.—
(3) Idem. — A person who contravenes subsection 45(8) or 76(11) (publication of identifying information) or an order prohibiting publication made under clause 45(7)(
c) or subsection 45(9), and a director, officer or employee of a corporation who authorizes, permits or concurs in such a contravention by the corporation, is guilty of an offence and on conviction is liable to a fine of not more than $10,000 or to imprisonment for a term of not more than three years, or to both. COURT FILE No.: Belleville Registry 16/11 DATE: 2013·03·13 Citation: Highland Shores Children’s Aid Society v. N.P. , 2013 ONCJ 151 ONTARIO COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: Highland Shores Children’s Aid Society, Applicant, — AND — N.P. (mother)and J.T.(father) Respondents. Before Justice W.
Malcolm Heard on January 11, 2013, January 29, 2013, January 31, 2013, February 28, 2013 and Submissions on March 1, 2013 Reasons for Judgment released on March 13,2013 Christopher Rous and Cynthia Law .................................................... for the Applicant Society Isak Feuer ................................................................................... for the Respondent father, J.T. Cheryl Lean ............................................................................ for the Respondent mother, N.P.
Malcolm J.: Background [ 1 ] The Highland Shores Children’s Aid Society (the Society) brought its application on June 8 th , 2012 for Society wardship concerning the child S.P-T. , born June 6, 2012. The application was amended to Crown wardship on November 18, 2012. [ 2 ] The mother of the child is N.P. (hereinafter noted as the mother) and the father is J.T. (hereinafter noted as the father). The mother is 25 years of age and the father is 32 years of age.
The parents have had a relationship with each since other February 2011 although they knew each other prior. [ 3 ] The mother is on Ontario Disability Support Plan (ODSP) for her developmental delay. The father works as a heavy equipment operator at a scrap metal yard in Napanee earning $1000.00 per week. [ 4 ] When their child was born they were living in Belleville but subsequently moved to Napanee in September 2012. Prior to the birth of the child they resided in Trenton which allowed the mother to have more contact with her family.
Child’s apprehension at birth [ 5 ] The Society has been involved with the mother since the birth of her first child C.P. born January 2011. That child was apprehended at birth by the Society. The father of the child is not J.T. The child C.P. now lives with her biological father and the mother enjoys supervised access every Wednesday in Belleville. Return of child to the care of her parents [ 6 ] When S. P-T. was born, she was apprehended from the care of her mother at the hospital.
A warrant was not obtained because of the lateness of the hour (late afternoon) and the worker’s belief that a Justice of the Peace would not be available. She should have tried to obtain a warrant. After a temporary care hearing on June 25, 2012 Justice E. Deluzio ordered the child returned to her parents’ care subject to very strict supervision. On July 18, 2012 she was ordered back into the temporary care of the Society by Justice Deluzio because the parents did not abide by the terms of interim supervision.
She has remained in care since that date. [ 7 ] Some of the terms of supervision were the following: the parents to enrol in couple’s counselling; the parents to refrain from alcohol use; the parents to maintain a telephone which the mother would be able to access at all times; there will be no domestic conflict between the parents; the father will continue with addictions counselling; and the parties will sign consents to allow the Society to obtain information from service providers for the parents.
The parents did not abide by these terms while the child was in their care or since that time. [ 8 ] At the settlement conference held on November 8 th , 2012, four days for trial in December 2012 were set. At the trial management conference on November 28 th , 2012 the parents indicated their plan was for the child to be placed in the care of the mother’s father, George P. and his partner. The first day of trial was vacated to allow the parties to negotiate an agreed statement of facts as to the protection findings. Agreed statement of facts [ 9 ] On December 12, 2012 an agreed statement of facts was filed.
The parents agreed that the child should be found in need of protection under section 37(2)(b)(i), risk of physical harm, and 37 (2)(g), risk of emotional harm. [ 10 ] The terms of the agreed statement of facts are as follows: • The parents acknowledged that they were not in a position to care for S. P-T. However they believed that they could make the necessary changes to their lives to allow them to do so in the future. They asked that S. P-T. be placed in the care of Ms. P’s father and his partner. • While S P-T. was in her parents’ care the Society offered them intensive support.
Despite that support, the parents were unable to comply with the terms of supervision. • Ms. P. and Mr. T. moved to Napanee as of September 1, 2012 from Belleville. • The Society has facilitated or made referrals for the parents to: addiction services; Healthy Babies; parenting programs (Triple
P) and hair and urine drug screen. • Ms. P. and Mr. T. have had an up and down relationship, characterized by police involvement, allegations of spousal abuse by the Society which is denied by the parents and Ms. P. leaving their joint apartment for a few days to cool down. • Mr. T. appears to continue to use alcohol, which also seems to be somewhat of a trigger in his relationship with Ms. P. Mr.
T. denies the use of alcohol for the past months. [ 11 ] Trial dates in January and February 2013 were provided and the December dates were vacated to allow for the grandfather to be assessed by the society. [ 12 ] On the first day of trial on January 11, 2013 the parties were not ready to proceed and the grandfather had not met with the Society.
The trial was then adjourned to January 28, 2013. Position of the parties at trial [ 13 ] The position of the Society at trial was that the child should be made a Crown ward with no access for purposes of adoption. [ 14 ] Until submissions were made the position of the parents was not clear. The evidence of the parents seemed to suggest that the child should be placed with them immediately. However at the end of trial, counsel for the parents submitted that the child should remain a Society ward for a further three months because the child had not been in care for a year and therefore had not exceeded the time that a child may remain in the care of the Society under Section 70(1)(
a) of the Act. During this time the parents propose they be allowed access in their home and community and they would access services. The expert evidence and the witnesses [ 15 ] An assessment concerning the child C.P. under
section 54 of the Child and Family Services Act (the Act) was completed by Eileen Bonner of the Family Court Clinic at the Counselling Services of Belleville and District (CSBD). Dr. Christopher Cooper administered psychological evaluations of the parties. Their reports were completed in April 2012. The Society asked that those reports be received in this proceeding and they were tendered as evidence under section 50(1)(
b) of the Act. Mr. T. was assessed in the C.P. matter although he was not the biological father. [ 16 ] I find that report of Dr. Cooper and the report of Ms. Bonner are relevant to this proceeding and the reports and their testimony is admissible into evidence. All parties agreed that Dr. Cooper is an expert in the field of psychological assessment. Further the parties agree that Ms. Bonner is an expert in the field of parenting capacity assessments. Both Dr. Cooper and Ms.
Bonner have testified in this court on other occasions and I accept that they are experts in the areas as agreed to by the parties. [ 17 ] Ms. Bonner has a master’s degree in social work and a bachelor’s degree in psychology. She has worked with high risk children since 1987. I found her evidence to be carefully presented, balanced and well-reasoned. She presented both the strengths and weakness in the parents’ plans. [ 18 ] Dr.
Cooper has a doctorate in psychology and has practiced in psychology primarily at the Kingston Family Court Clinic for the last 30 years although he is recently retired and now in private practice. His evidence was also very helpful, well-reasoned and balanced. [ 19 ] The assessment and the evidence of Ms. Bonner and Dr. Cooper raised issues of Ms. P.’s developmental delay; her inability to retain information and apply it to caring for her child; her difficulties in trusting others and general relationship struggles; conflict in the parents’ relationship with each other; and Mr.
T.’s struggles with abusing alcohol. [ 20 ] Additional evidence for the Society was provided by Family Service Workers Elizabeth Bosma-Donovan and Angie Cascone, Children’s Services Worker Shannon Seath, Supervised Access worker Julie Hoskins, Ontario Provincial Police Constable Kyle Hillier and Linda Hill, the Respondents’ former landlady in Belleville. [ 21 ] Each of the Respondents testified, as did Mary P., N. P.’s grandmother. At my request George P., N.P.’s father testified.
He had been on the witness list for the parents but they did not intend to call him. [ 22 ] The Respondents did not lead any independent or professional evidence. [ 23 ] The mother and the father testified that their problems stemmed from the Society involvement, they had not been given enough opportunity to parent their child and the child should be returned to their care. [ 24 ] Although in the Agreed Statement of Facts the parents consented to the child being found in need of protection, in their testimony they minimized the concerns of the Society.
Among the Society concerns were: the developmental delay of Ms. P. and the impact on her ability to care for her child; Ms. P.’s ability to cooperate with the Society or other service providers; the conflict between Mr. T. and the mother; the father’s abuse of alcohol; and the lack of initiative in the parties to access services to address the concerns. N.P.’s developmental delay and the impact on her ability to care for her child [ 25 ] The evidence is clear that the mother has cognitive limitations. This is apparent even from her deportment and demeanour in the court room.
When being asked whether she wished to swear an oath on the Bible before giving her evidence she explained that she goes
to church and she is not a liar. [ 26 ] When asked why she was in receipt of ODSP she testified that she didn’t know and that her father had got her a job before. She said that she wished to return to school and study to be a lawyer. [ 27 ] This evidence is in marked contrast to the evidence of the Society, the assessors and what I observed at trial. [ 28 ] Dr. Cooper conducted clinical interviews of the parties and administered the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale [WAIS-IV], Child Abuse Potential Inventory [CAPI] and Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory [MCMI-III]. [ 29 ] Ms P. was administered the WAIS-IV.
There are five components: Full scale IQ in which she scored in the mild range of developmental delay (1 st percentile); verbal comprehension index in which she scored in the mild range of developmental delay (2 nd percentile); perceptual reasoning index in which she scored in the mild range of developmental delay (1 st percentile); working memory index in which she scored in the borderline range 8 th percentile) and processing speed in which she scored in the borderline range (8 th percentile). [ 30 ] As to her functioning Dr.
Cooper testified that “one would expect she would have some difficulties, again, across a fairly broad spectrum of functions. Education, employment, as you say, everyday skills and so on.” [ 31 ] When asked about Ms. P’s ability to parent a child independently he said : “With a score in that range, you would usually be concerned about the ability to function independently. Because of judgment, anticipation, weak executive functioning, planning, foresight. The ability to decide between alternative courses of action and to anticipate various kinds of difficulties.
So, in my experience, usually with scores in that range, one’s usually trying to assess whether or not there are adequate supports from family and so on that might support such an individual”. [ 32 ] When asked what type of support she may need he answered: “ One is usually looking at a situation, say, where a young mother might be living at home with very supportive parents.” [ 33 ] Dr. Cooper also testified that whether Ms. P. could learn the skills she would need to care for a child would depend on her personality and whether she would ask others for help and recognize her limitations.
Further she would need to work cooperatively with others. He said that the support that is required is pervasive. [ 34 ] He also questioned her judgment in deciding to have another child before she could show that she had a solid relationship with Mr T., there was no substance abuse and that she had taken programming. Only then would he suggest that she would talk to her doctor or Children’s Aid Society about the possibility of having another child. At trial she said that she had named the child who is now in vitro.
This shows poor judgment to me to plan to have another child before she has addressed the problems in her life now. [ 35 ] Dr. Cooper also testified that the difference in the cognitive functioning or intelligence of Mr. T. and Ms. P. was statistically significant and may cause a power imbalance in their relationship. He had no literature to support this position however. [ 36 ] When Ms. Bonner conducted her assessment she was able to speak to Ms. P’s family physician, Dr. McIntyre and also review the application for ODSP made in 2006.
The doctor in support of the ODSP application indicated that the mother had a moderate limitation and required support in the areas of impulse control and behavior; recognition of normal dangers in the home or community; memory; finances and utilizing commercial services. She also wrote that the mother could achieve a measure of independence with the assistance of counseling and an adult protective worker. [ 37 ] During the trial the mother was not engaged in counseling, although she is on a waiting list and she had just obtained a temporary adult protective worker.
When she resided in Belleville she had an adult protective worker and had some counseling through the women’s shelter.
[ 38 ] The mother testified at trial that she had, in the past, been diagnosed by a doctor as being bipolar and was put on medication. She said that after conversations with her lawyer and counselor she now understands that the doctor should not have made that diagnosis because he was not a psychiatrist. She has ceased taking the medication that she was earlier prescribed. This concerns me. Her grandmother testified that she thought her granddaughter was taking medication for her bipolar disorder. [ 39 ] Ms.
Bonner testified that the mother had difficulties telling time except on a digital clock and sometimes struggled with knowing when to feed her child. [ 40 ] The mother also had difficulties reading her child’s cues. Ms. Bonner, when watching her interact with her daughter C.P., noted that the child was very engaged in playing with a toy. The child was banging the toy obviously very delighted to be playing with it. Despite this, the mother took the toy away and offered other toys. The child then became very distraught.
The mother took the child and tried to distract her while the child was pointing to the toy wanting it back. This would be a cue that most people would have understood but Ms. P did not. [ 41 ] Ms. Cascone, Ms. Bosma-Donovan and Ms. Seath, the Society workers for Ms. P., and Ms. Hoskins, the supervised access worker, have witnessed Ms. P’s cognitive limitations. They all have commented on her difficulty in telling time.
This sometimes affects her ability to heat a baby bottle with formula in time for feeding or she has put food in the microwave for too long making it too hot for her toddler to eat right away. [ 42 ] The workers have also observed that the mother needs extensive support, assistance and redirection. She will say that she forgets how she was told to do something when caring for S. P-T. She has a two year old daughter and it would be expected that she would be familiar with such things as diapering and feeding an infant yet she still struggles. [ 43 ] Ms.
P. had numerous supervised access visits with her children each week and despite the teaching, advice and modeling of the supervised access worker and child protection worker she still struggles meeting the basic needs of her daughter. [ 44 ] The workers testified that when C.P. was young she would become inconsolable in her mother’s care. Yet the supervised access worker, the receptionist or the protection worker could take the child and comfort her almost immediately. [ 45 ] The workers also had to warn Ms. P. repeatedly about her excessive use of the phone during access visits.
Eventually the phone had to be removed from the room. They also had to remind her to greet her daughters at the beginning of an access visit. [ 46 ] Ms. Bosma-Donovan testified that the Society decided to have a supervised access worker right in the room with the mother to identify cues and give strategies and ideas to help soothe C.P. The mother also had to be prompted as to when to feed her child and to talk in a softer voice to avoid startling her daughter when she was tired and fussy. Unfortunately this information did not always remain with Ms.
P. and workers had to remind her about care of the child, recognizing cues, talking softly and not being on the phone from visit to visit. [ 47 ] Now that C.P. is older Ms. Bosma-Donovan testified that the mother struggles when the child has a new kind of behaviour and she has to adapt to it. For example she becomes very critical when her daughter C.P. doesn’t share a toy with S. P-T although her older daughter is only two years of age. She appears to use adult reasoning for things that a two year old is doing.
She once called her mother to complain that her daughter was not sharing with her. [ 48 ] The child, S.P-T. is a much quieter baby than her sister and does not get as distressed. However because she is so quiet the workers are concerned that her needs could be neglected. She does not cry when she is hungry or wet as C.P. did. [ 49 ] The workers and supervised access worker testified that Ms. P. can interpret a cry as the baby needing to be fed or changed but other issues would be hard for her to understand. Further given that S.
P-T is so quiet there is a risk for the child’s needs not to be met. [ 50 ] When S. was returned to the care of her mother, C.P’s access continued to be supervised by Julie Hoskins a very experienced, kind and sensible supervisor. I found her to be a credible and fair witness. She testified that the mother rarely missed a visit. [ 51 ] Ms. Hoskins was aware when Ms. P was pregnant with S.P-T. although Ms. P. denied being pregnant for some time. Ms. Hoskins was supervising a visit with C.P. when Ms. P. was in labour. Ms. P. told Ms. Hoskins that her water had broken the night before and Mr.
T. had asked whether Ms. Hoskins could take her to the hospital to see if she was really in labour. Ms. Hoskins did take Ms. P. to the hospital at 9:30 a.m. in the morning and stayed with her until after the baby was born. Neither Ms. P’s mother nor father attended at the hospital. Mr. T., who had gone to work in the morning, did not arrive until after noon. [ 52 ] After S. was returned to the care of her parents Ms. Hoskins was in their home for a visit with C.P. Ms. P. had made a number of bottles for S. and had left them on the counter. She said that Mr.
T. said she could leave them unrefrigerated for 24 hours. Ms. P.’s landlady, Ms. Hill, had also observed a number of bottles on the counter with formula. [ 53 ] On July 11, 2012 Ms. Hoskins was supervising a visit with C.P. S. had been returned to the care of her parents. Ms. P. was at the home of her grandmother and had been there since the night before, although Ms. Hoskins was there to supervise Ms. P’s interactions with C.P., she couldn’t help but be concerned about S. [ 54 ] S. was very quiet, having a difficult time staying awake and had vomited twice. Ms. Hoskins had to direct Ms.
P. to sit S. up after vomiting instead of first cleaning her face. The mother said she thought her oldest child had given the baby cheese and that was causing the vomiting but Ms. Hoskins said the vomit was projectile vomiting.
[ 55 ] On questioning Ms. P., Ms. Hoskins discovered that the last two diaper changes had been dry and there had been vomiting before she arrived. She tried to feed the child and keep the child awake. She was very concerned. Eventually Ms. P. called the telehealth nurse and the child was taken by ambulance to the hospital. It was fortunate that Ms.
Hoskins noticed that the child was quite lethargic and vomiting more than one would expect. [ 56 ] Although the grandmother and mother appeared to notice the child’s symptoms, with the busyness of the older child and the other activity in the house they didn’t react until the child had to be taken to hospital. It is difficult to know if the child would have been taken for medical attention without the encouragement of the worker. [ 57 ] Ms. Hoskins testified that despite numerous reminders Ms. P. still had difficulties in holding S. appropriately and not like a rag doll.
She continued to struggle with time especially remembering nap time or feeding times for the girls. [ 58 ] Ms. Hoskins said that eventually she told Ms. P. that she needed to do more for the girls herself. As an example she described a visit when Ms. P. and the two girls were at the shopping mall. When Ms. P. was expected to provide all the care for the girls she couldn’t manage it. [ 59 ] Ms. Cascone testified that Mr. T. said to her that Ms. P. could not handle the two girls together and he did attend a supervised access visit with both girls. Unlike Ms.
P. he was able to care for his daughter and was able to read her cues and provide care without intervention. [ 60 ] Given her difficulty in reading the cues of her children, I agree that she should be well supervised when in a caregiving role and an unsupervised child in her care would be at risk of physical harm and emotional harm. I accepted the evidence of the society workers that N.P. struggled with her care of the children together and individually. [ 61 ] I find this despite the evidence of Mary and George P. who indicated that there were no problems with N.P.’s care of the child S.P.- T.
I accept that they love their granddaughter and daughter but I accept the Society evidence. [ 62 ] The mother means only the best and she loves her child very much but she lacks the capacity to care for her child without careful and constant supervision. I agree with Ms. Bosma-Donovan’s observation the mother has great love for her child and great will to be a good mother but lacks the capacity. The ability and willingness of the parents to work with the Society or the community services [ 63 ] With constant daily, vigilant, consistent and capable support the mother may be able to care for a child.
Unfortunately she does not always wish to accept the direction of the workers as to the care of her children. The workers have indicated sometimes she can take direction but then will need reminders on the next day when she sees her child. Further the workers cannot live with her on a daily basis. [ 64 ] The mother was having very frequent access with extensive supervision and direction and mentoring. Despite this she has had problems with reading her children’s cues and providing care. [ 65 ] Dr. Cooper assessed Ms.
P. as scoring in a significantly elevated way in the histrionic scale and the paranoid scale in the MCMI-III. As to the histrionic scale at page 13 of his report he describes persons who score in this range to tend to be over-reactive, volatile, engaging and provocative. Impulsive and highly emotional responsiveness is typical. They tend to be attention- seeking and cognitively flighty. [ 66 ] In her interactions with the Society and even her own family and her landlady and the friends of her partner there is evidence of conflict. One day Ms.
P. will work well and cooperatively with someone and the next day she will not. [ 67 ] She said her father would care for her child but he did not even meet with the Society or pick up the application. She has said that her sister is a support to her and then at another time she is not. [ 68 ] She has confided to Ms. Bosma-Donovan one day about the conflict in her relationship with Mr. T. The worker emotionally supported her and took her to a woman’s shelter. Subsequently the mother she says that she didn’t disclose any abuse to the worker and she wants a new worker. I accept that Ms.
Bosma Donovan was concerned about the emotional and physical safety of the mother. [ 69 ] Ms. Hoskins, who appears to be a kind, tolerant supervised access worker, came to believe that she could no longer work with the mother because of the conflict and the mother’s refusal to take direction. [ 70 ] Dr. Cooper in his report at page 13 indicated that people who have an elevated paranoid scale may have vigilance toward and mistrust of other. Further there may be defensiveness against anticipated criticism and deception is typical. The evidence at this trial shows that the mother has these characteristics.
She has a mistrust of the Society. She indicates that if the Society was not in her life there would be no conflict with Mr. T.; this is despite the fact that Ms. P. has had a number of incidents of conflict with family members and other persons in the community even involving police involvement. Some predate the birth of her children. These incidents were outlined in Ms. Bonner’s report at page 10 to 13. [ 71 ] Ms. P testified that Mr. T.’s friends do not like her. She accused one friend, Mr.
Davis of trying to run her over with a vehicle in October 2012. [ 72 ] She said that she stopped going to one parenting group because of conflict with others in the group. She said that some of the girls were rude to her. [ 73 ] Ms. P. testified that she hasn’t signed consents for the Society to monitor her service providers. She does not trust them. [ 74 ] Mr. T testified that he hated Ms. Bosma-Donovan and although he got along alright with Ms. Cascone he really had little contact
with her. [ 75 ] He testified that he has had no access with his daughter since around Christmas. He complained that the Society would not change his Tuesday evening access which started at 5:00 pm until later so he could attend after work. There is no evidence that he asked his employer if he could leave work a have hour earlier on Tuesday. The drive from Napanee to Belleville is approximately 30 minutes. The Society had a volunteer driver arranged to take him. The Society arranged for Sunday access instead but he rarely exercised it. He has not demonstrated a willingness to work with the Society.
He asked that the child be moved to Napanee for access. This shows that he is not being child focussed and puts his needs first in this regard. [ 76 ] He says that his boss would be flexible for him to care for his child if she was returned but he hasn’t taken time off work for access or counselling. He moved to Napanee for a fresh start but it took him away from access to his previous counsellor. [ 77 ] I find that it is not just the Society with whom Ms. P. has conflict and it would be very difficult for any agency or person to supervise Ms. P. and her children if they were in her care. Further, Mr.
T. has not shown a willingness to engage meaningfully with services. The conflict between Ms. P. and Mr. T. [ 78 ] Ms. P. has confided in all of the Society workers and Ms. Hoskins about the conflict in her relationship with Mr. T. [ 79 ] On May 17, 2012 she told Ms. Bosma-Donovan that Mr. T. had verbally and physically abused her the night before. Ms. Bosma- Donovan testified that Ms. P. said it started when Mr. T. had told her to stay in the family home since they only had one key. Instead Ms. P. went out and celebrated C.P.’s birthday. [ 80 ] She was not home when Mr.
T. came home from work and he was very angry. He stayed out the entire night and the next morning called her a whore and said he had a gun and was going to shoot Robbie, her previous boyfriend, and her parents. He threatened to call the Children’s Aid Society. The next day he put all her things outside the home. Ms. Bosma-Donovan took Ms. P. to a shelter but within days Ms. P. had returned to the family home. [ 81 ] Ms. Bosma-Donovan spoke to Mr. T. that morning and he claimed that he didn’t remember anything about his alleged threats.
She said he seemed to be hung over or suffering from having had too much to drink the night before. She had wanted him to go to addictions counselling. [ 82 ] Ms. P. at trial minimized what happened. She said that Mr T. didn’t call her dirt; he just gestured to dirt in his hand and said this is you. I fail to see the distinction. [ 83 ] In June 2012 there was a report of another domestic incident. [ 84 ] Ms. Hill, the parties’ former landlady, lived upstairs from the parents in Belleville from approximately March 2012 to August 2012.
She lived in the upstairs part of the house and the parents in the downstairs. [ 85 ] She described many loud arguments between the parties. [ 86 ] In the summer she said there was a terrible argument where she banged on the floor to stop the fighting. The next day Ms. P. showed her bruises on her arm and she took photos of them. Ms. P. testified that the bruises were just from Mr T. pushing her out of the way. She said she bruises very easily. [ 87 ] Mr T. described the incident when there was a loud argument at the Hill home as him being “weirded out” by Ms. P. counting out her pills on the kitchen counter.
He didn’t believe what the pills were for and flushed them down the toilet. Ms. P was extremely upset. These were pills to help her lactate. [ 88 ] When things had come to a head with the continual weekend fighting and the noise, Ms. Hill said she didn’t want to come home to her own home. She suggested to Mr T. that she could use the last month’s cheque and he could leave at the end of August. He agreed. She asked for a notice of his intention to leave. He wrote a very vulgar and rude note similar to the language he used to describe Ms. Hill and Ms.
P. on other occasions. [ 89 ] In August 7, 2012 the worker received a call from the police about another domestic incident. Ms. P. told Ms. Bosma-Donovan that she had been locked out of the home by Mr. T. and she wasn’t sure if the relationship was over. [ 90 ] The police were called to the home in Belleville but they did not testify nor do I have the occurrence report. [ 91 ] Ms. P. subsequently recanted her disclosures about these problems with Mr. T. or has minimized them. [ 92 ] Ms. P. also confided in Ms. Cascone. She told her that in Halloween of 2011 Mr T. pushed her on to a shelf.
In the summer of 2012 when S. was in their care Mr. T. pushed her on her shoulder when she was sitting on the bed feeding the baby. [ 93 ] In Napanee in September 2012 there was an incident when Mr. T. had been walking down the street with another woman and Ms. P. confronted him and there was a verbal argument which was so loud that the police were called. [ 94 ] Ms. P. told Ms. Bonner that Mr. T. made all the decisions. She didn’t know that they were moving to Belleville from Trenton until they were moving. She was very upset that she didn’t have all her things from the Trenton home for many weeks. Mr.
T. said he was tired and couldn’t get her things but she was obviously upset. [ 95 ] After the family moved to Napanee in September 2012 there were several calls to the police and further Ms. P. made two reports that Mr. T. was missing.
[ 96 ] Constable Hillier of the Napanee Ontario Provincial Police testified that he had been at the home of Ms. P. and Mr. T. on October 29, 2012, one day after a 911 call had been made. Ms. P. wanted to speak to Officer McTavish to whom she had spoken the night before. She said that she was only having a problem with Mr. T’s friend, Mr Dave Jarvis and not with Mr. T. She said that Mr. Jarvis had tried to run her over with his vehicle and she had been injured. She made no complaint about Mr. T. [ 97 ] The officer then spoke to Mr. T separately.
The version he received was remarkably different than that given by Ms. P. Mr. T. said he and Ms. P were separated and he wanted the police to make her leave. He called her a “crazy fucking b...h” and a “fucking c..t”. Although this language was very rude, obscene and abusive the officer said the friend was much more aggressive than Mr. T. [ 98 ] There was some discussion about their child and Mr. T. said that he didn’t care because the child was probably not his. [ 99 ] The officer checked the home and it was cool and the fridge was empty. Mr. T. said he was not living there. The officer took Ms.
P. to a shelter. He said that he would not have left the couple together because he feared that there would be a domestic incident. [ 100 ] I accept the evidence of the officer as credible. He is experienced and had an independent recollection of the incident because of the language used by Mr. T to describe Ms. P. It is telling that one day after Ms. P. told the police that Mr. T. and his friend tried to run her over, she has recanted. She is telling the officer that there is nothing wrong with Mr. T. yet Mr T. is very abusive and wants her to be removed from their home. [ 101 ] Ms.
P. minimizes the relationship problems and testifies that Mr T. says things he shouldn’t. She says he says things he doesn’t mean. She also admits that she wishes that he put her first before his friends. [ 102 ] In discussions with Ms. Bonner and Dr. Cooper, the parents minimize the conflict in their home. Further Mr. T. indicates that the conflict involving the police in his relationship with his older daughter’s mother was due to that mother and not him. [ 103 ] Dr. Cooper also commented on the power imbalance that may be caused in a relationship when one party has very low cognitive abilities.
The evidence does support a power imbalance. [ 104 ] The evidence supports that Ms. P. didn’t make any of the major decisions. When Mr T. moves out of the home to cool off or spend time with his friends, Ms. P. doesn’t know where he is or how long he will be gone. It would appear sometimes she does not have enough food. This is not a mutually respectful relationship with two equal partners. [ 105 ] There is risk of harm to a child while she is in a home with this type of conflict. There is no real evidence of counselling or acknowledgement of the unhealthy relationship that the parents have with each other. Mr.
T. has not taken any counselling and he testified that the PARS program is only for those men convicted of assaulting their partners. He does not recognize that he has a problem. Mr. T’s alcohol use [ 106 ] Although Mr. T.’s alcohol use is not the major concern of the society , when there has been domestic conflict between the parties there is usually evidence that Mr. T. has been drinking. His recent urine screens are negative however. [ 107 ] Ms. Hill describes seeing Mr T. frequently on weekends in an impaired state. This would be on Friday after work. Mr T. testified that he would drink after work.
In the summer of 2012 he testified that he was drinking “near beer” and brought a receipt to prove it. Ms. Hill describes hearing loud arguments of the parents when he was drinking. She testified that she was at court only because she was subpoenaed to come. She is independent of all parties. I accept her evidence. [ 108 ] Ms. Hill also seemed a very kind person. She described Mr T. leaving the home for days at a time. She would take “care” packages of food for Ms. P. because she was concerned. She was worried about Ms.
P. [ 109 ] I note that Mr T. was convicted of impaired driving and driving without a license in 2011. He went to jail because he could not pay the fines. He seemed to minimize his alcohol problems. He has not had any alcohol treatment since before the birth of his child. He has seen the counsellor in Napanee only once and doesn’t know their name. He says that he has not had anything to drink for two months but his child has been in care for almost nine months. [ 110 ] He has not had his license since approximately 2003 when he first lost his license for impaired driving.
Over the years he had a number of other tickets and he owes $2000 in fines. He says he will have the fines paid by this summer and he can have his license. [ 111 ] Although Mr T. may be abstaining from alcohol at present, I find that his drinking has negatively affected his relationship with Ms. P. and he would be a risk to the safety of a young child in his care if his problem remains untreated. I don’t accept his blanket denial of having any problem with alcohol. The parents’ plan [ 112 ] The parents testified that they believe Napanee has more services for them than Belleville.
However, now Mr T. must take a cab to work. When he lived in Belleville his boss picked him up and drove him to work. Mr. T said that he has a grandfather in Napanee but he has not seen him and didn’t know he was in Napanee when he decided to move there. [ 113 ] Ms. P. has three visits with her child each week and the Society has provided a volunteer driver to take her to Belleville. [ 114 ] Mr. T. says that their new home is almost on the grounds of the hospital. I concede that this location may be helpful for the parties but most medical care occurs in a doctor’s office or clinics and Ms.
P’s and their child’s doctor practices in Brighton and that doctor she has been Ms. P.’s physician since Ms. P. was born. [ 115 ] Mr. T. has seen an addictions counsellor once before Christmas. Ms. P is on a waiting list for counselling. Only when the mother has completed her individual counselling, and the father has finished his addictions counselling, will the counsellor see them together for
relationship issues. There is no evidence as to when this is likely to occur. [ 116 ] Ms. P. has a temporary adult protective worker. She is taking courses because of her pregnancy. She has obtained information about day care for their child but the details are rather vague. [ 117 ] The parents ask for a delay in permanency for their child for three months and then perhaps another six months. They suggest that because the foster mother has expressed an interest in adopting the child if she becomes a Crown ward there is less urgency to make a final order. I disagree.
There is no guarantee the foster mother can adopt and even if she can, the process should begin as soon as possible. [ 118 ] Before I can extend the time that their child remains in care I must be sure that there is likely to be a change in the parent’s situation. The parents seem to believe that they are entitled to have their child remain in care for 18 months before a final decision must be made. That is not the law. [ 119 ]
Section 70 should be read with Rule 33 of the Family Law Rules. Under the timetable for child protection cases, a hearing is to be held within 120 days or four months. The original trial in this matter was scheduled for six months after the application was commenced. Even that was too long. Because of the parents’ submission that the maternal grandfather should be assessed as a kin placement the trial was ad-journed another three months. [ 120 ] The child cannot wait in limbo while the parents decide whether they need services. Mr. T. was told that he could benefit from a PARS type program in April 2012.
In June 2012, Justice Deluzio directed the parents to refrain from domestic conflict, to enrol in couple’s counselling, the father to take addictions counselling and the parents to sign consents to allow the Society to monitor their progress. Nothing has been done in eight months since Justice Deluzio made that order. [ 121 ] I have no reason to believe that anything will happen in the next three months. The parents don’t believe they have any problems. Ms. P. believes the Society has caused her problems and she says she is a lot smarter than they think. She says that she and Mr. T get along fine.
I disagree with her based on the evidence. [ 122 ] Further Ms. P. is expecting another child in June. She hopes that the Lennox and Addington Society will allow her to keep her child. [ 123 ] I find that Ms. P. will not be able to satisfy the court that she can work with the Society and other services or engage in couples’ counselling in the next three months. Mr. T. would also need to attend PARS or some equivalent program or counselling and addictions counselling as well. [ 124 ] Further because of Ms. P.’s cognitive limitations she would need constant supervision and Mr.
T. has not been able to reduce his work although he indicates that he can work four days a week. [ 125 ] I must consider what is in the best interests of the child pursuant to section 37(3) of the Act. If S. P-T. is made a Crown ward she will have a chance to be adopted into a permanent home. [ 126 ] If I make the child a Society ward for another three months and the parents are not able to miraculously turn their lives around we will be facing status review and another trial.
It is not probable that the parents can do this. [ 127 ] The child’s need to be in a secure place as a member of a family may occur within an adoption.
To delay a final decision is only to delay the inevitable of an order of crown wardship for the child. [ 128 ] The child does not know her father and to terminate that relationship is not likely to cause harm. [ 129 ] Although the child appears to enjoy contact with the mother I believe that continued access would impair the child’s ability to be adopted. [ 130 ] I am satisfied that the access is enjoyable, but not beneficial and meaningful to the child. [ 131 ] The decision that I am making is not made lightly. This is the most serious and important decision that a judge can make.
The parents obviously love their child very much and the father is a very hard worker. [ 132 ]I am satisfied that the Society has assisted the family to the best of their ability and considered all of the less intrusive measures. The society would have assessed Mr. George P. as a care giver if he had returned the phone calls of the society and picked up the application form. The society held a family group conference to try to resolve the issues.
A permanency planning meeting was organized and held but the parents did not attend. [ 133 ] The child cannot wait while her parents access services and change their lifestyles. The parents have been aware for a year prior to the birth of their child of what they need to do and they have not done it. The evidence is overwhelmingly in favour of the claim of the society. [ 134 ] The child is entitled to a permanent home. [ 135 ] Therefore I order that the child S.
P-T. be made a ward of the Crown and placed with the Highland Shores Children’s Aid Society, without access, for purposes of adoption. [ 136 ] The April 4, 2013 date is vacated. Because I had indicated to the parents that I would not have a decision until that date I recommend, but do not order, that the Society allow access until that date.
Released: March 13, 2013 Signed: “Justice Malcolm”
Loading document…