R. v. P.(M.), 2013 ONCJ 190
Opinion
WARNING The court hearing this matter directs that the following notice should be attached to the file: This is a case under the Youth Criminal Justice Act and is subject to subsections 110(1) and 111(1) and
section 129 of the Act. These provisions read as follows: 110. Identity of offender not to be published. —
(1) Subject to this section, no person shall publish the name of a young person, or any other information related to a young person, if it would identify the young person as a young person dealt with under this Act. . . . 111. Identity of victim or witness not to be published.—
(1) Subject to this section, no person shall publish the name of a child or young person, or any other information related to a child or a young person, if it would identify the child or young person as having been a victim of, or as having appeared as a witness in connection with, an offence committed or alleged to have been committed by a young person. . . . 129. No subsequent disclosure.— No person who is given access to a record or to whom information is disclosed under this Act shall disclose that information to any person unless the disclosure is authorized under this Act.
Subsection 138(1) of the Youth Criminal Justice Act , which deals with the consequences of failure to comply with these provisions, states as follows: 138. Offences.—
(1) Every person who contravenes subsection 110(1) (identity of offender not to be published), 111(1) (identity of victim or witness not to be published) . . . or
section 129 (no subsequent disclosure) . . . (
a) is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years; or (
b) is guilty of an offence punishable on
summary conviction. COURT FILE No.: Kitchener Y268-10 DATE: 2013·04·11 Citation: R. v. P.(M.) , 2013 ONCJ 190 ONTARIO COURT OF JUSTICE sitting under the provisions of the Youth Criminal Justice Act , S.C. 2002, c. 1 BETWEEN: HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN — AND — M.P., a young person as defined by the Youth Criminal Justice Act Before Justice G. F. Hearn Application heard on February 4, 7, 8, 12, 26, 27 and March 26, 28, 2013 Ruling on Application released on April 11, 2013 C. Jennison and L. Fritzley ........................................................................................ for the Crown C.
Parry ............................................................................................... counsel for the accused M.P. HEARN J.:
INTRODUCTION: [ 1 ] L.M. was stabbed to death by the young person M.P. in the late evening hours on March 29, 2010. At the time of his death L.M. was 49 years of age. The young person M.P. was 16 years of age, two weeks shy of his 17 th birthday which was to fall on […], 2010. [ 2 ] L.M.’s tragic death was the result of a series of stab wounds, 19 in number, six of which were potentially lethal on their own, applied by the accused young person using a knife which he had on his person. 911 was called by one of those present in the apartment where the stabbing took place.
Emergency personnel arrived, first aid was administered but in spite of valiant efforts L.M. died. [ 3 ] The young person fled the scene prior to the arrival of the police and emergency personnel but eventually surrendered the following day, March 30, 2010. He has remained in custody since that time. [ 4 ] M.P. was initially charged with first degree murder and a preliminary hearing in this matter commenced and continued over a number of days in April of 2011.
During the course of the preliminary inquiry the young person re-elected to be tried by this court and entered a plea of guilty to a charge of second degree murder. [ 5 ] Prior to the plea the Crown pursuant to the provisions of the Youth Criminal Justice Act (hereinafter referred to as the Y.C.J.A. ) served notice on the accused that an adult sentence would be sought for the charge before the court. The hearing of that application commenced February 4, 2013.
On March 28, 2013 submissions were completed and the ruling on the application was then reserved to today’s date. [ 6 ] In passing, it should be noted that this matter has been protracted somewhat since the date the plea was entered for many reasons. These include the necessity for the preparation of a pre-sentence report, assessments by two psychiatrists, and a voir dire which continued over a number of days with respect to the admissibility of certain statements made by the young person.
The voir dire was required to determine whether or not such statements would be available to the psychiatrists conducting the assessments. [ 7 ] Over the course of the hearing of the application the court has heard from numerous witnesses. As well, pursuant to s. 71 of the Y.C.J.A. the court has heard from the mother of the young person as well as the young person himself. [ 8 ] The issue to be addressed in this application is whether or not a youth sentence if imposed on M.P. would be of sufficient length to hold the young person accountable for his offending behaviour.
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE OFFENCE : [ 9 ] An agreed statement of facts is filed in this matter.
That agreed statement of facts incorporates by reference a number of the exhibits filed during the course of the preliminary inquiry and also includes summaries of evidence of various witnesses called at the preliminary inquiry. [ 10 ] It is important for the purposes of this ruling to outline the facts agreed to in order to give context to the incident and to outline the circumstances, not only with respect to the night of the murder itself, but the events leading up to the death of L.M. [ 11 ] The incident happened at the apartment of L.M. which he shared with other individuals, one of whom was S.C., a 35 year old woman, the mother of four children and the stepmother of C.B. who also resided in the apartment with her partner L.G. and their six month old child.
On occasion the young person M.P. would also stay at the apartment in the room occupied by S.C. with whom he had been involved in a relationship since October of 2009. [ 12 ] On the day of the offence the young person, S.C. and L.M. had been consuming quantities of alcohol. As well, at least S.C. and M.P. were also consuming marijuana. Around 9:00 p.m. M.P. left the residence as a result of an argument with S.C. in order to avoid that argument and to apparently “cool off” (hereinafter called the “walkabout”).
He was gone for approximately 30 to 45 minutes and while outside of the residence met a number of individuals with whom he was familiar. [ 13 ] He returned to the residence at about 10:00 p.m. S.C. then re-initiated the argument with M.P. He again attempted to leave but S.C. blocked his way and convinced M.P. to stay in the residence. They returned to S.C.’s bedroom, the argument then resumed and L.M. entered the bedroom apparently to intervene and to attempt to end the argument.
During the course of that intervention M.P. stabbed L.M. [ 14 ] S.C. yelled for assistance from L.G. who was in the residence at the time. L.G. came to the bedroom and pulled M.P. off L.M. who was lying on S.C.’s bed. M.P. dropped the knife he had used and fled the apartment without either his shoes or coat. M.P. remained in a forested area until about midnight and then attended at the residence of a friend, K.C., where he remained for the evening. He advised K.C. that he had “snapped” and stabbed L.M. when L.M. had attempted to intervene in the argument between he and S.C..
M.P. spent the evening at the residence of K.C. and turned himself into the police on March 30, 2010 in the afternoon hours. [ 15 ] The agreed statement of facts includes a
summary of evidence of various witnesses who testified during the course of the preliminary inquiry. A further
summary of that evidence is as follows: Evidence of A.L. : [ 16 ] Ms. A.L. is a high school friend of M.P. and was also a friend of M.P.’s former girlfriend. She referred to the poetry written by M.P. as “dark”. She stopped seeing M.P. regularly when M.P. began his relationship with S.C. of whom she disapproved. She believed that S.C. sold drugs, had schizophrenia and she did not like her. She also had attempted to assist M.P.’s mother in having
her son separated from S.C. without success in 2009. [ 17 ] She met M.P. after M.P. had left the apartment of L.M. and S.C. initially on the evening of March 29, 2010 during the “walkabout”. She described M.P. as walking quickly but seeming “all right”. However, while walking with M.P. he displayed some anger and when she asked him what was wrong he indicated that he was upset, “really hot-headed” and was so mad that he wished to “slash somebody’s throat”. He then pulled a knife out of a case in his back pocket and showed it to the witness.
They ran into another friend, the knife was again produced, other comments were made by M.P. suggesting aggressive behaviour but there were no such movements or gestures. The witness attempted to address M.P.’s apparent unhappiness and they parted ways. Evidence of S.F. : [ 18 ] S.F. had brief contact on the “walkabout” with M.P. and noted that he appeared to be voicing suicidal thoughts. This witness stated such thoughts were consistent with things he had voiced to her in the past. This witness was aware that M.P. had scars on his arms from self-cutting previously.
Evidence of D.V. : [ 19 ] D.V. also had contact with M.P. during M.P.’s “walkabout”. He stated that he was in fact the owner of the knife that was used in the murder and had traded it to M.P. for another knife several months before the incident. He stated M.P. appeared to be nervous, scared and angry. This witness had further contact with M.P. around midnight after the murder when M.P. had attended at K.C.’s apartment. At that time M.P. had indicated to the witness that he thought he had killed someone and did not know what to do. According to this witness M.P. looked sad, upset and “wasn’t himself at that time”.
Evidence of T.G. : [ 20 ] T.G. also met M.P. on the evening of the walkabout. His contact was brief with M.P. but he felt that M.P. was angry. He also met M.P. later at the K.C. residence where he observed M.P. to have blood on his hands and noticed that M.P. was not wearing any shoes. Evidence of K.C. : [ 21 ] K.C. had contact with M.P. after the event on the night in question when M.P. attended at her apartment. She noted M.P.’s upset and stated M.P. indicated that he had “stabbed somebody”. This witness noticed cuts and blood on M.P.’s arms which M.P. indicated to Ms. K.C. were self-inflicted that evening.
This witness also had noted cuts to the forearms of M.P. that had been self- inflicted before March 29, 2010. [ 22 ] M.P. stayed the evening at her apartment and the next morning indicated that he had stabbed L.M. a number of times when L.M. had intervened in an argument between he and S.C. during which S.C. had accused M.P. of being unfaithful to her with his former girlfriend. M.P. indicated to the witness that he had left the apartment to cool off and when he returned S.C. continued to drink and argue. L.M. attempted to intervene, M.P. had “snapped”, stabbed L.M., dropped the knife, and ran from the apartment.
Evidence of L.G. : [ 23 ] L.G. was also an occupant of the residence at the relevant time. He described S.C. as a drug addict, alcoholic and schizophrenic. He also described L.M. as an alcoholic. He noted that M.P. was not going to school at the time and frequently hung out with S.C. instead of going to school and on the weekends would often sleep over.
He noted M.P. when at the apartment would be with S.C. in her bedroom. [ 24 ] This witness’s evidence as summarized in the agreed statement of facts indicates that a delivery company delivered alcohol paid for by L.M. to the residence on the day in question on two occasions. Although L.M. had requested delivery of a third bottle, that order had not been placed by L.G. as L.M. was intoxicated and had started to fall asleep in a dining room chair that evening. This witness testified that L.M. was kind to M.P. and M.P. was also kind to L.M.
The two never argued, although L.M. disapproved of the relationship between M.P. and S.C.. This witness described the poetry written by M.P. as being violent but also stated the poetry was M.P.’s way of dealing with his emotions after learning that M.P.’s stepfather had sexually molested M.P.’s sister. [ 25 ] The
summary of this witness’s evidence indicates that M.P. was noted by him to be quiet and did nothing to cause the witness to fear him. He described the day of the events as M.P. arriving in the afternoon and L.M. ordering alcohol. According to this witness, two 26-ounce bottles of whiskey were consumed and alcohol was provided to M.P. The witness described L.M., S.C. and M.P. as all sharing the alcohol. He also could detect the odour of marijuana coming from S.C.’s room.
He noted the argument to have taken place between M.P. and S.C. which resulted in M.P. leaving the residence and S.C. returning to her room and slamming the door. [ 26 ] M.P. returned, and according to the other witnesses attempted to leave again but was blocked by S.C., and returned to her bedroom where the argument resumed. L.M. appeared to be agitated, went into the room and this is when the stabbing took place. This witness described how he entered the room, grabbed M.P. who then looked at him, dropped the knife and ran from the apartment. It was this witness that called the paramedics.
Evidence of C.B. : [ 27 ] C.B. was another resident of the apartment. She has known M.P. since public school and S.C. was her stepmother. She indicated that M.P. would spend time at the apartment with S.C., skip school and M.P. and S.C. would drink alcohol and smoke drugs in S.C.’s bedroom. C.B. testified that M.P.’s consumption of both increased after his relationship with S.C. began. [ 28 ] She spoke of the presence of the knife that M.P. carried with him and his dark poetry which was apparently an interest he shared with S.C..
She acknowledged that S.C. had schizophrenia and a history of drug and alcohol abuse and spoke of the sharing of the
alcohol the evening of March 29, 2010. [ 29 ] She testified to the events of M.P. leaving the apartment, returning and the argument re-initiating. The facts also indicate that prior to the stabbing she had not seen any conflict between L.M. or M.P. and the actions of M.P. came as a complete surprise to her. Evidence of S.C. : [ 30 ] S.C. also gave evidence. She acknowledged that she has schizophrenia and that she and L.M. drank every day. She acknowledged drug use. She spoke of her relationship with M.P., their common interest in writing poetry together and how that relationship had evolved from October of 2009.
She spoke of how M.P. had confided in her that M.P.’s stepfather had sexually abused his sister and that was a cause at the time of extreme emotional upset for M.P. [ 31 ] The agreed statement of facts sets out her evidence with respect to the date of the events. She acknowledged the consumption of alcohol, the providing of same to M.P., how a bottle had been ordered and shared among L.M., M.P. and herself. They were “drinking shot for shot” and a second bottle was ordered, and some marijuana was consumed. Again the alcohol was shared with M.P. She acknowledged that all three were “pretty drunk”.
She acknowledged the argument initiated, M.P. left the apartment and returned. She re-initiated the argument upon his return and M.P. attempted to leave but she convinced him to come back. They then returned to her bedroom and she described how she again became argumentative and confrontational with M.P. L.M. then entered the bedroom, said something to M.P. who then grabbed L.M. and began stabbing him in the back. L.G. entered, pulled M.P. off of L.M., M.P. then dropped the knife and fled without coat or shoes.
VICTIM IMPACT STATEMENTS: [ 32 ] There have been a number of victim impact statements filed and read into the record by the Crown. (See Exhibit #4). One or more of the members of the family of L.M. have been present in court throughout this matter from the initial stages through the preliminary inquiry and on many days since. [ 33 ] The victim impact statements are from members of L.M.’s family as well as others. Without exception the statements speak of the impact the tragic and unnecessary death of L.M. has had on them and those they love.
Again, without exception, the victim impact statements are eloquent and heartbreaking. [ 34 ] They speak of the fine qualities of the victim who by all accounts was a compassionate and generous individual. They speak understandably of the anger and rage created by the way L.M. died. [ 35 ] The actions of M.P. on the evening of March 29, 2010 have obviously impacted and will continue to impact the victims who have provided the statements to the court.
POSITION OF THE PARTIES : [ 36 ] The Crown by virtue of the application before the court seeks M.P. to be sentenced as an adult notwithstanding that he was 16 years of age at the time of the offence. If sentenced as an adult, M.P. would receive a life sentence and parole eligibility would be no less than seven years. (See s. 745.1 of the Criminal Code ). In calculating the period of imprisonment served for the purposes of s. 745.1 , s. 746 of the Criminal Code is applicable and M.P. is entitled to include any time spent in custody since the day he was taken into custody until the day the sentence is imposed.
It is possible for a young person who is subject to an adult sentence to remain in a youth facility until the age of 20 and beyond if so ordered by the court. (See s. 76(2) and 76(9) of the Youth Criminal Justice Act ). [ 37 ] The defence position is that M.P. should be sentenced as a youth. Pursuant to s. 42(2) (q)(ii) of the Youth Criminal Justice Act a young person such as M.P. who is found guilty of second degree murder is liable to a sentence not to exceed seven years comprised of “(
A) a committal to custody, to be served continuously, for a period that must not, subject to subsection 104(1) (continuation of custody), exceed four years from the date of committal, and (
B) a placement under conditional supervision to be served in the community in accordance with
section 105;”. [ 38 ] Although the Crown does not agree that a youth sentence is appropriate, both counsel do agree that the provisions of the Y.C.J.A. in place on March 30, 2010 are the appropriate provisions to consider. Both also agree that no minimum penalty is prescribed on a charge of second degree murder pursuant to the Y.C.J.A. and the sentence must contain a custodial portion and a placement under conditional supervision. There is no minimum period of custody required, although the maximum period is four years.
Neither is there a limit on the duration of the conditional supervision portion of the sentence for second degree murder.
The defence submits, and the Crown agrees as does the court, if a youth sentence is imposed then the court could impose a period of custody something less than four years and a period of conditional supervision for the remaining portion of the sentence so long as the total period comprises seven years. (An example put before the court by the defence was that the court could impose one day of custody and six years, 364 days of conditional supervision.) The defence advocates for a youth sentence which would, having regard to the pre-trial custody, be in the range of 12 to 23 months further custody to be followed by three to five years supervision in the community. [ 39 ] If sentenced as a youth, the conditions attaching to the conditional supervision portion of the sentence would be imposed by the court shortly before the custodial period is to expire and any breach of the conditions could result in the suspension of the
supervision order and require that the offender be returned to custody. (See s. 105 to s. 109 of the Youth Criminal Justice Act). Further,pursuant to s. 98 of the Youth Criminal Justice Act in cases of offenders who would constitute a danger to the public the AttorneyGeneral may apply to the court to continue custody and deny conditional supervision.
Pursuant to s. 96 of the Y.C.J.A., conversely theProvincial Director, if satisfied that the needs of the young person and the interests of society would be better served by doing so, couldmake a recommendation to the court that the young person be released from custody and placed under conditional supervision so thateffectively a further custodial portion of the sentence can be varied to such supervision. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK: [40] The Crown has made an application to have M.P. sentenced as an adult.
The main issue to be determined is whether themaximum youth sentence that could be imposed under the provisions of the Y.C.J.A. is of sufficient length to hold M.P. accountable forhis behaviour. The criteria to be considered and the test to be applied is found within s. 72 of the Youth Criminal Justice Act. Section72(1) reads as follows: “72.
(1) In making its decision on an application heard in accordance with
section 71, the youth justice court shall consider theseriousness and circumstances of the offence, and the age, maturity, character, background and previous record of the young person andany other factors that the court considers relevant, and (
a) if it is of the opinion that a youth sentence imposed in accordance with the purpose and principles set out insubparagraph 3(1)(b)(ii) and
section 38 would have sufficient length to hold the young person accountable for his orher offending behaviour, it shall order that the young person is not liable to an adult sentence and that a youth sentencemust be imposed; and (
b) if it is of the opinion that a youth sentence imposed in accordance with the purpose and principles set out insubparagraph 3(1)(b)(ii) and
section 38 would not have sufficient length to hold the young person accountable for his orher offending behaviour, it shall order that an adult sentence be imposed.” [41] Section 72(2) provides that the onus of satisfying the youth justice court as to the matters referred to in subsection (1) inthis case is on the Crown. Dealing with the nature of that onus, the Ontario Court of Appeal in Regina v. A.O., 2007 ONCA 144, [2007] O.J. No. 800, discussed the onus upon the Crown. The court held that the wording of the
section in permitting an adultsentence “if the youth court is of the opinion that an adult sentence is required to hold the young person accountable for their offendingbehaviour” requires a very careful consideration of all relevant factors but does not place a “very heavy burden” on the Crown and doesnot require proof beyond a reasonable doubt. [42] At paras. 37 and 38 of Regina v. A.O., supra, the court stated: “...we recognize that the decision to impose an adult sentence upon a young person is a very serious one and should only be taken aftercareful consideration of all the relevant factors.
As the youth court judge pointed out, the imposition of an adult sentence can lead tovery severe consequences for the young person. [38] The youth court judge reasoned that in order to ensure that the most serious interventions are reserved for the most seriouscrimes, as mandated by the
preamble to the YCJA, the burden of proof is not mere satisfaction, but rather ‘a very heavy onus to satisfy’,as he put it. With respect, we would not describe the onus in those terms. Section 72(2) imposes an onus of satisfying the court, nothingmore.
However, in applying that onus, it is important that a youth justice court bear in mind the very serious consequences of an adultsentence for the young person, so as to only order an adult sentence when necessary to fulfill the objectives of the YCJA.” [43] In deciding whether to impose an adult sentence the court should be guided by the principle that accountability ofyouthful offenders is limited in comparison to adults. This principle is set out specifically in s. 3(1)(b)(ii) of the Y.C.J.A. which isreferred to within s. 72.
Section 3(1)(b)(ii) states that the criminal justice system for young persons must be separate from that of adultsand emphasizes the following: “... fair and proportionate accountability that is consistent with the greater dependency of young persons and their reduced level ofmaturity,”.
The limited maturity, judgment and inexperience of young persons means that they should not be held as accountable as an adult whomay have committed the same crime. [44] Also incorporated into s. 72 is s. 38 of the Y.C.J.A. which requires that in determining whether to impose an adult sanctionthe court should determine what a youth sentence would be that includes just sanctions that have meaningful consequences and promoterehabilitation and reintegration into society, thereby contributing to the long-term protection of society. [45]
Section 38 of the Y.C.J.A. as it stood at the time of the commission of this offence reads as follows: “38.
(1) The purpose of sentencing under
section 42 (youth sentences) is to hold a young person accountable for an offence through theimposition of just sanctions that have meaningful consequences for the young person and that promote his or her rehabilitation andreintegration into society, thereby contributing to the long-term protection of the public.
(2) A youth justice court that imposes a youth sentence on a young person shall determine the sentence in accordance with the principlesset out in
section 3 and the following principles: (
a) the sentence must not result in a punishment that is greater than the punishment that would be appropriate foran adult who has been convicted of the same offence committed in similar circumstances;
(
b) the sentence must be similar to the sentences imposed in the region on similar young persons found guilty of the sameoffence committed in similar circumstances; (
c) the sentence must be proportionate to the seriousness of the offence and the degree of responsibility of the young person for thatoffence; (
d) all available sanctions other than custody that are reasonable in the circumstances should be considered for all young persons, withparticular attention to the circumstances of aboriginal young persons; (
e) subject to paragraph (c), the sentence must (
i) be the least restrictive sentence that is capable of achieving the purpose set out in subsection (1), (ii) be the one that is most likely to rehabilitate the young person and reintegrate him or her into society, and (iii) promote a sense of responsibility in the young person, and an acknowledgement of the harm done to victims and the community.
(3) In determining a youth sentence, the youth justice court shall take into account (
a) the degree of participation by the young person in the commission of the offence; (
b) the harm done to victims and whether it was intentional or reasonably foreseeable; (
c) any reparation made by the young person to the victim or the community; (
d) the time spent in detention by the young person as a result of the offence; (
e) the previous findings of guilt of the young person; and (
f) any other aggravating and mitigating circumstances related to the young person or the offence that are relevant to thepurpose and principles set out in this section.” The focus of the inquiry under s. 72 is on the question of whether the youth sanctions that can be imposed under the Act are of sufficientlength to hold the youth accountable. Still, s. 72 itself incorporates the purpose and principles specifically set out in s. 3(1)(b)(ii) and s.38 into the test to be applied. By incorporating the purpose and principles of s. 3(1)(b)(ii) and s. 38 into the test the
section also requiresthe youth court to engage in the same type of weighing of factors as occurs when sentencing any other young person. PRINCIPLES SET OUT IN THE CASE LAW: [46] Both the defence and the Crown have provided books of authorities and the court has had an opportunity to review thecases provided as well as other cases. Each sentencing of an individual, whether a youth or an adult, of course is an individual exerciseand the facts of no two cases are identical, nor are the circumstances of the offender before the sentencing court.
However, the case lawprovided does assist the court in dealing with the principles of accountability, meaningful consequences and diminished moralblameworthiness. [47] Section 3(1)(b)(ii) specifically sets out that the criminal justice system for young persons must be separate from that ofadults and emphasizes among other things the fair and proportionate accountability that is consistent with the greater dependency ofyoung persons and their reduced level of maturity. In Regina v.
D.B., [2008] S.C.C. 25, the Supreme Court of Canada held that an adultsentence cannot be imposed on a youth unless the Crown rebuts the presumption that a youth is entitled to diminished moralblameworthiness or culpability.
The court stated there the principle of fundamental justice that young people are entitled to apresumption of diminished moral blameworthiness and culpability which flows from the fact that because of their age they haveheightened vulnerability, less maturity and a reduced capacity for moral judgment. [48] The case law indicates the principle of accountability requires an approach that is “offender-centric” and which excludesadult sentencing principles such as deterrence and denunciation. The court appreciates, however, that the approach is not offenderexclusive. (See Regina v. B.W.P. and Regina v.
B.V.N. 2006 SCC 27 , [2006] S.C.J. No. 27). In Regina v. Ferriman, [2006]O.J. No. 3950, in dealing with the issue of a sentence to hold a young person accountable the court noted that such a sentence mustachieve two objectives. At para. 38 the court indicated: “It must be long enough to reflect the seriousness of the offence and the offender’s role in it, and it must also be long enough to providereasonable assurance of the offender’s rehabilitation to the point where he can be safely reintegrated into society.
If the Crown provesthat a youth sentence would not be long enough to achieve these goals then an adult sentence must be imposed.” [49] In Regina v. A.O., supra, the court discussed the principle of accountability at paras. 42, 46, 47, 48, 49: “[42] The combined effect of ss. 72, 3 and 38 is to identify accountability as the purpose that the youth court judge must considerwhen deciding an application to impose an adult sentence on a young person.
Accountability is achieved through the imposition ofmeaningful consequences for the offender and sanctions that promote his or her rehabilitation and reintegration into society. Thepurpose of accountability in this context would seem to exclude accountability to society in any larger sense or any notion of deterrence. ... [46] In our view, accountability in this context is the equivalent of the adult sentencing principle of retribution as explained by
Lamer C.J.C. in R. v. M. (C.A.), (1996), (SCC), 105 C.C.C. (3d) 327 (S.C.C.) at paras. 80 and 81: Retribution in a criminal context, by contrast, represents an objective, reasoned and measured determination of an appropriatepunishment which properly reflects the moral culpability of the offender, having regard to the intentional risk-taking of the offender, theconsequential harm caused by the offender, and the normative character of the offender’s conduct.
Furthermore, unlike vengeance,retribution incorporates a principle of restraint; retribution requires the imposition of a just and appropriate punishment, and nothingmore. … Retribution, as well, should be conceptually distinguished from its legitimate sibling, denunciation. Retribution requires that a judicialsentence properly reflect the moral blame-worthiness of that particular offender. The objective of denunciation mandates that a sentenceshould also communicate society’s condemnation of that particular offender’s conduct.
In short, a sentence with a denunciatory elementrepresents a symbolic, collective statement that the offender’s conduct should be punished for encroaching on our society’s basic code ofvalues as enshrined within our substantive criminal law. [Underlining in original, italics added.] [47] In our view, for a sentence to hold a young offender accountable in the sense of being meaningful it must reflect, as does aretributive sentence, “the moral culpability of the offender, having regard to the intentional risk-taking of the offender, the consequentialharm caused by the offender, and the normative character of the offender’s conduct”. [Underlining omitted.] We see no other rationalway for measuring account-ability. [48] The need to consider the normative character of an offender’s behaviour necessarily requires the court to consider societalvalues.
But what the court cannot do is add on to a youth sentence an element of general deterrence or denunciation. This concept ofaccountability is consistent with this court’s decision in R. v. W. (R.E.) (2006), (ON CA), 205 C.C.C. (3d) 183 atparas. 40-42, where the court noted the focus of the YCJA on the best interests of the young person, and at para. 43, in which itconsidered the exceptional circumstances in which a court can impose a custodial disposition under s. 39(1)(
d) of the Act: The scheme of the YCJA suggests that the exceptional case gateway can only be utilized in those very rare cases where thecircumstances of the crime are so extreme that anything less than custody would fail to reflect societal values. It seems to me that oneexample of an exceptional case is when the circumstances of the offence are shocking to the community. [49] This view of the meaning of accountability is also consistent with the other principles of sentencing to which the youth courtjudge is directed under s. 38, especially those set out in ss. 38(3)(
a) and (b): degree of participation, harm to the victim and whether theharm was intentional or reasonably foreseeable. These principles speak to retribution as defined by Chief Justice Lamer in R. v. M.(C.A.), supra.” [50] Further, in Regina v. Todorovic [2009] O.J. No. 3246 the court noted again the principle of accountability at paras. 10and 12. “The notion of accountability immediately raises the question – accountable to whom?
While the answer to that question will necessarilyvary according to the individual actions or decisions for which a person is being held to account, in the case of the YCJA one mustpresume that the persons to whom the young person is intended to be held accountable are the members of the community in which theyoung person committed the offence and which has suffered the harm resulting from it. ...
It would follow from that conclusion that in determining whether the sentence to be imposed on a young person ‘would have sufficientlength to hold the young person accountable for his or her offending behaviour’ that sentence must be measured, at least in part, bywhether it will be seen by the community as accomplishing that goal, that is, holding the young person accountable for the offendingbehaviour.” [51] In Regina v. Lights, [2007] O.J.
No. 1516, the court noted that under the Y.C.J.A. accountability is the watchword andthat an adult sentence should be imposed when a youth sentence would not be long enough to meaningfully address the seriousness of theoffences, the offender’s role in them and his or her rehabilitation and ultimate reintegration into society. (See para. 45). [52] Accountability then is achieved through the imposition of meaningful consequences for M.P. and sanctions to promotehis rehabilitation.
The sentence must be of sufficient length to reflect the seriousness of the offence and M.P.’s role in the offence takinginto account M.P.’s decreased maturity which the Crown argues here is absent. The sentence cannot include elements of generaldeterrence or denunciation and must be long enough to provide reasonable assurance that M.P.’s rehabilitation into the community canbe done in a manner not compromising the safety of the community.
Meaningful consequences deals both with the custodial portion ofany sentence imposed and the sanctions designed to promote M.P.’s rehabilitation and reintegration into the community. [53] In dealing with the case law that has been provided it is trite to say that the facts of each case differ significantly fromeach other and from the circumstances of the offence before the court now. Still, the application of the principles as set out in thosecases has been of assistance to the court. ISSUE OF PRE-TRIAL CUSTODY: [54] As noted, M.P. has been in custody for just over three years at this time.
If sentenced as an adult, that period of custodywill be considered with respect to parole eligibility. If a youth sentence is imposed, the question then becomes whether or not such pre-trial custody must be considered in the reduction of any further period of custody to be served or whether it can simply be a factor to beconsidered in the court deciding to impose a youth sentence.
[55] This is an important issue here since if the court is required to consider and credit pre-trial custody M.P. would have lessthan a year in custody to serve if a youth sentence is imposed. That may not be sufficient to deal with the issue of accountability eventhough such a sentence might otherwise be appropriate and consistent with the principles under the Y.C.J.A. and would be a factor whichon its own might prompt the court to impose an adult sentence. [56] In considering the issue of pre-trial custody the cases seem to be at odds. Section 38(3)(
d) of the Y.C.J.A. indicates that acourt in determining a youth sentence shall take into account the time spent in detention by the young person as a result of the offence. There is nothing in the legislation itself that assists the court in determining how the court is to take into account that pre-trial custodyand the case law seems to confirm that the sentencing judge has a residuary discretion in that regard. [57] In Regina v. D.W., [2008] ONCA 268, the Ontario Court of Appeal was dealing with an appeal by a young person from atrial court’s decision that he be sentenced as an adult.
The young person had been in custody for two and a half years at the time ofsentencing and the sentencing judge felt he was required to give the young person credit for that period of time in pre-trial custody and,as a result, felt further that the remaining maximum youth sentence that could be imposed would not be sufficient to hold the youngperson accountable nor promote his rehabilitation.
The Court of Appeal set aside the adult sentence and replaced it with the maximumyouth sentence and noted at para. 3 of the decision as follows: “The trial judge’s approach was in error because although he was required to take pre-trial custody into account, he was not required todirectly deduct the time spent in pre-trial custody. Instead, the trial judge had broad discretion to take pre-trial custody into account as aconsideration in deciding whether the appellant would serve a youth or an adult sentence.” [58] This view was unsettling for the court in Regina v. J.S.R., [2009] O.J.
No. 1162 (Ontario Superior Court), where the courtwas also dealing with an application by the Crown to have a youth sentenced as an adult. There, the court expressed difficulty with thedecision in Regina v. D.W., supra, and found it troublesome that the court could impose a sentence on a young person that failed to giveany credit whatsoever for the pre-trial custody. [59] The Court of Appeal in Regina v. J.S.R., 2012 ONCA 568 , [2012] O.J.
No. 4063, in dealing with this particularissue found the trial judge had not erred simply because it was in fact a matter of discretion as to how a sentencing judge was to considerthe pre-sentence custody and, secondly, the conclusion reached in that case, which resulted in an adult sentence being imposed, wasbased on the factors set out in s. 72(1) of the Y.C.J.A. and not reliant on the pre-sentence custody submissions in any event. [60] In Regina v.
L.G., [2009] ONCA 402, the Court of Appeal specifically stated at para. 19 that a trial judge is not requiredto subtract pre-trial custody from a four year maximum custodial sentence set out in s. 42(1)(q)(ii) of the Y.C.J.A. The court effectivelyconfirmed that any reduction for time served was a discretionary matter. [61] Further, in Regina v. T.(D.D.), (2010) 2010 ABCA 365 , 265 C.C.C. (3d) 49, the court held that s. 38(3)(
d) mustbe interpreted to permit discretion to “take into account” the period of pre-disposition custody in ways other than by granting a reductionin a custodial period to be served.
There, the court found that the trial judge had made no error in determining that he could “take intoaccount” the pre-trial custody by sentencing the respondent as a youth rather than as an adult. [62] I take it from the case law and the principles stated that within the application that is before the court to impose an adultsentence the court, although having an obligation to take into account the pre-trial custody of M.P., also has a wide discretion as to howthat accounting is to be reflected in the sentence imposed.
If the court decides that a youth sentence is appropriate and consistent withthe purpose and principles set out in the Y.C.J.A., the court can either give credit for the pre-trial custody or consider giving no credit atall in arriving at that decision. It is also clear from the case law (see Regina v. B.(T.), (ON CA), [2006] O.J.
No. 584(Ontario Court of Appeal)) that the residuary discretion afforded to the sentencing judge with respect to credit for pre-sentence custodyalso includes the discretion to decline giving full credit to the pre-trial custody. [63] Looking then at the impact of the pre-trial custody, if sentenced as an adult M.P. would receive a sentence of lifeimprisonment with eligibility for parole at the end of seven years. M.P. has served approximately three years and therefore would beeligible for parole within four years.
Upon release as a result of a life sentence M.P. would be subject to parole for the rest of his life. [64] If sentenced as a youth, the maximum sentence is seven years, no more than four of which can be served in custody andthree supervised in the community. This, of course, is subject to the provisions of the Y.C.J.A. which permit the Crown to apply to turnthe conditional supervision into custody as well.
If M.P. receives no credit for time served and is sentenced as a youth, he couldtheoretically then spend another four years in custody (making a total of seven years) and be under supervision for three years thereaftersubject, of course, to the Crown making an application to have the conditional supervision portion also converted to custody. [65] In dealing with the impact of any sentence that might be imposed, it is important to note that one option that has beendiscussed by counsel and the psychiatrists when they were giving their evidence was the availability of an intensive rehabilitativecustody and supervision order under the Y.C.J.A.
However, upon further review the Provincial Director has determined that M.P. is notan appropriate candidate for that program and is of the view that M.P.’s needs can be met with the “existing structures available withinthe criminal justice system”. Accordingly, that is not an option available to the court, even if so inclined, on sentencing. (See Exhibit#7). FACTORS UNDER S. 72(1):
(1) Seriousness and Circumstances of the Offence: [66] Murder is the most serious criminal offence under the Criminal Code. Still, in dealing with the serious nature of thecharge before the court I keep in mind that Parliament when passing the Y.C.J.A. contemplated that a youth who committed murder couldbe sentenced as a youth and, if sentenced as an adult, would be subject to a lesser period of parole eligibility. This approach is consistent
with the principle set out in the case law that young persons presumptively have diminished moral blameworthiness for their criminal acts. This is due, as noted previously, to their age, heightened vulnerability, less maturity and a reduced capacity for moral judgment. [ 67 ] There is simply no doubt, however, that the taking of another’s life, as here, is a serious matter and must be, without exception, addressed as such by the court. The actual stabbing of L.M. by M.P. was brutal, violent, senseless and, on the facts before me, unprovoked.
M.P. stabbed L.M. 19 separate times and six of those wounds would have been potentially lethal on their own. The repeated number of stab wounds clearly indicates an intention to kill L.M. who by all accounts was intoxicated and simply trying to act as a peacemaker. [ 68 ] The offence itself then is a serious matter. The court, however, notes s. 72(1) not only requires the court to consider the seriousness of the offence but also the circumstances of the offence.
These circumstances include more than just the act itself and the court must look at the context within which this crime was committed. [ 69 ] Here, the accused was 16 years of age at the time of the offence. He was by all accounts a troubled youth who as recently as the fall of 2009 had been admitted to a psychiatric unit of a hospital. He was involved in a dysfunctional relationship with a woman many years older who had significant mental health issues as well as substance abuse issues. In the context of that relationship alcohol and drugs were supplied regularly to the young person by S.C. and others.
S.C. was ready and willing to engage in such activity as well as talk of death and take
part in the writing of dark poetry with the young person. [ 70 ] The offence on the facts that I have was spontaneous. There was no planning, no deliberation, no premeditation, although the court does note the comments made during “the walkabout” by M.P. The court finds those comments were simply posturing by a young person who was under the influence of alcohol and/or other substances at the time and was angry.
That anger was not directed at L.M. at that point on “the walkabout” but was internal anger that the young person had been experiencing for many reasons including the actions of his stepfather who had sexually abused his sister. [ 71 ] There was no animus at all between L.M. and M.P. They in fact were friends and had consumed alcohol together on the day in question. L.M. was not targeted. There is nothing in the evidence to indicate that there was any acrimony or dispute between L.M. and M.P. that evening or before.
The Crown alleges the murder took place in a fit of “drunk and jealous rage” but there is nothing whatsoever in the facts to indicate there was any jealousy on the part of M.P. towards L.M. [ 72 ] An argument initiated by S.C. with both participants having their judgment impaired by many things, but certainly by alcohol, led to the intervention by L.M.
The young person himself had previously left the apartment to “cool off” during the first stage of the argument, returned and then when the argument appeared to be re-initiated by S.C. attempted to leave again but he was dissuaded from leaving the apartment by S.C.. [ 73 ] At the time of the murder and for months leading up to the murder M.P. was involved in a relationship with a much older female that was inappropriate and dysfunctional at all levels. The actions of M.P. were impulsive and nothing else.
The results are tragic, of course, but to argue that M.P. committed the offence out of jealousy is unfounded on the facts. Although M.P. had a record, there is nothing of a violent nature reflected by that record nor is there any indication at all that he had previously used the knife in such a manner, although the facts acknowledge that he carried it on his person. Indeed, the only violent acts that appear to have been taking place with the knife prior to the incident were when M.P. self-inflicted wounds as his way to assist dealing with his depression.
M.P. up to that point had sought refuge to deal with his anger and depression by using alcohol, drugs and self-cutting. He had been hospitalized as a result of suicidal ideations in the fall of 2009. [ 74 ] M.P. acknowledged that following the disclosure regarding the stepfather he engaged in writing dark poetry and fantasizing with respect to an alter ego. He was not well and he was involved in a relationship that was not ever likely to be one that would nurture his well-being. The Crown argues that M.P. was effectively living an adult lifestyle and showed an advanced level of maturity.
However, the court finds that the facts indicate the complete opposite. M.P. was a 16 year old struggling with many issues and was lacking proper adult guidance. The court agrees with the defence position that M.P. at the time of the offence was immature in every sense of the word. [ 75 ] The event should never have taken place, of course, but I think it is important to understand the circumstances of the young person in March of 2010 when considering the facts surrounding the murder. M.P. himself acknowledged to others that he effectively “snapped” when L.M. tried to intervene.
A frenzy ensued and tragically L.M. died. There had been nothing leading up to the event that would indicate L.M. and M.P. had issues at all, let alone that evening. The unplanned nature of the act is evidenced by the fact that the young person when, apparently appreciating what he had done, left the apartment on a March evening without coat or shoes and hid out in a forest before eventually showing up at a friend’s apartment. [ 76 ] In my view, the circumstances of this particular murder differ very much from the factual scenarios set out in most of the cases provided by both counsel.
The actions of M.P. here were the result of a momentary surge of anger by a troubled 16 year old.
(2) The Age, Maturity, Character, Background and Previous Record of the Young Person: [ 77 ] M.P., as noted, was 16 years of age at the time of the offence and turned 17 shortly after the event. There is a great deal of material that has been filed with the court and evidence has been called with respect to M.P.’s background, character and progress while in custody. (
a) Pre-Sentence Report and the Evidence of Lorie Seremetovski: [ 78 ] There is before the court a thorough and helpful pre-sentence report prepared by Lorie Seremetkovski. Ms. Seremetkovski has been involved with the young person while he has been in custody since August of 2010 and in addition to preparing the report gave evidence during the course of the hearing of the application. [ 79 ] The report sets out the background of the young person. M.P. has a youth record which is relatively minimal and includes
periods of probation. None of the offences noted in the record indicate a pattern of violence at all on the part of the young person. [ 80 ] The young person was born on […], 1993 and was 16 years of age, almost 17, at the time of the offence. His biological father has had little contact with him since he was a very young age and the young person has resided primarily with his mother. His mother has always been supportive and has been present on each and every court appearance since the young person has been in custody.
He and one of his sisters share a biological father and M.P. has another sister who was born as a result of a relationship and ultimate marriage the mother had with B.P.. M.P.’s stepfather, Mr. B.P., sexually abused a sister of the young person. That abuse was discovered in 2006 and the impact of that abuse was significant and continued to be so on the young person. That impact is chronicled in the material before the court. Prior to that disclosure M.P. had already begun to have difficulties at school.
He had been bullied in Grade three and in 2003 when he was about ten years of age he was admitted to hospital after a teacher had noted markings around his neck. M.P. cannot recall what triggered this event but he does remember tying a cord around his neck at that time. He was hospitalized and then treated with medication for a number of years following that incident. [ 81 ] The young person upon his release from hospital seemed to have no issues at home but continued to act out in the school setting eventually leading to his mother homeschooling M.P. in 2005.
He returned to Grade eight in the mainstream school system in 2006 and it was that year he discovered the issue with his stepfather and his sister. It is the court’s understanding from the report that the mother did not wish to have charges laid and the police agreed notwithstanding that the stepfather had acknowledged the abuse of M.P.’s sister. [ 82 ] Following the disclosure, however, the stepfather moved out of the home and while his sister has received counselling with respect to the abuse and how to cope with it, M.P. refused to attend.
He obviously was an angry youth, started writing dark poetry and there were concerns about his academics as well as his behaviour. Family and Children’s Services had been involved as a result of the allegations of abuse and continued to be involved for a period of time. [ 83 ] M.P.’s drug and alcohol use started at a very young age of 13 and he increased such use which he states he did to help control his anger. His drug use continued in 2007 with marijuana being the drug of choice and he began associating with a negative peer group.
The young person acknowledges that he did not talk about his inner anger towards his stepfather with his mother despite the mother’s efforts. He had feelings of anger, depression and had suicidal ideations. [ 84 ] In early 2009 the young person met S.C. who then was approximately 32 years of age, had significant mental health and substance abuse issues. She was the mother of four children. Those children had all been placed in the care of a relative. M.P. began spending more time at S.C.’s apartment which she shared with L.M. The young person’s marijuana use escalated as did his alcohol consumption.
He had been in an age appropriate relationship but that relationship broke down and M.P. began spending more time with S.C.. [ 85 ] The young person continued to suffer emotional and mental health issues. He had episodes of self-cutting and in 2009 was admitted once again to the hospital where he was diagnosed with depression. No medication was provided and upon his release from the hospital his relationship with S.C. became an intimate one. M.P. had some insight into that relationship and recalls being confused, as noted in the pre-sentence report.
He and S.C. shared an interest in dark poetry and alcohol and drugs supplied by S.C. were part of that relationship. [ 86 ] Others moved into the residence of L.M. and S.C. and drug and alcohol use became prevalent for the young person. His mother expressed disapproval over the relationship he had with S.C. and notes that on one occasion when Ms. S.C. was away for a period of time M.P. moved back home where the mother noted M.P. was “sober, had some of his sense of humour back and was home as required”. [ 87 ] Unfortunately, upon Ms. S.C.’s return the relationship continued.
She and M.P. would have discussions about life and death and drugs and alcohol continued to be consumed up to and including the night of the murder. [ 88 ] The report notes that since his detention M.P.’s relationship with his mother has become stronger as has his relationship with his sisters. They maintain contact personally by phone calls, letters and other means. The mother reports that over the years M.P. has been in custody he has “matured tremendously”.
The mother reports that he is learning to deal with his emotions and recalls when he was first incarcerated for an extended period of time he would call her crying and expressing remorse for killing “his friend”. [ 89 ] His family has been extremely supportive and in fact have also learned lessons from the young person’s involvement with drugs.
One sister has completed a school project on the serious impact drugs and crime can and have had on various lives. [ 90 ] The pre-sentence report sets out the educational background of the young person and details the education plan that M.P. has been involved with while in custody. His current teacher Amy Stewart, who also gave evidence during the course of the hearing, noted to the author of the pre-sentence report that M.P. has matured since his first day in Ray of Hope and is a “pleasure to teach”.
The teacher has noticed his writings are much more positive than when he first was admitted to the institution and that she is “able to see how he is able to better deal with emotion, guilt and express remorse” by having him in the classroom every day. [ 91 ] His educational plan while at Bluewater where he was from October of 2010 until March of 2012 noted his strengths as being his verbal skills, participation in small groups, his creativity, physical education, art and computers.
The plan, however, did note that he struggled with organizing his material, some social emotional issues, anger management, expressive language, reading comprehension, time management and task completion. He was noted to be a slow and methodical worker but excelled at creative writing, showing an interest in what he was learning, putting thought and effort into his work and was willing to do extra work in order to better understand concepts.
One of the teachers at Bluewater noted that M.P. was an “excellent student in every way - well behaved, excellent manners” and showing “compassion towards others”. [ 92 ] Prior to his incarceration his high school performance had not been ideal. His marks were low, his attendance poor and he had only earned six credits towards his high school diploma. After his detention his performance has improved significantly and he has earned a number of further credits.
[ 93 ] It is clear, however, from the pre-sentence report that M.P. struggled in school. He is noted as early as Grade four to have shown frustration, emotional volatility and difficulty accepting responsibility, as well as low self-esteem.
There had been reports in the late 1990’s about inappropriate touching by a baby-sitter and the social worker involved at that time noted that M.P. wished to kill himself, had nightmares and appeared fatigued. [ 94 ] The report sets out the particulars of hospitalizations with respect to the young person and also notes his history while on probation from the orders made in 2008 and 2009. The previous probation notes indicate that M.P. was struggling with substance abuse issues and behavioural problems at home.
It was during the latter probationary period leading to the murder in March of 2010 that M.P.’s association with S.C. became a concern. This, as noted previously, led to M.P.’s beginning to self-cut and his eventual admission to the psychiatric unit of the Grand River Hospital in September of 2009 after he had voiced suicidal ideations to his mother. [ 95 ] Leading up to March of 2010 the young person had expressed concerns to his probation officer about his mental health, believing that he was a schizophrenic and was exhibiting the same symptoms as S.C..
No assessment, however, was ever completed as the events in March 2010 intervened. [ 96 ] The pre-sentence report sets out the history of the young person while in detention. The young person was originally at Hope Manor from March of 2010 until October of 2010. He was then transferred to Bluewater, returning to Ray of Hope (formerly Hope Manor) on March 6, 2012 where he has been since. The dates noted in the pre-sentence report with respect to his custodial history are incorrect and acknowledged to be so by the author of the pre-sentence report.
M.P. has now been in custody just over three years. [ 97 ] The records from all institutions have been filed as exhibits and workers were called to comment on M.P.’s progress or lack thereof while in custody. The primary workers at Ray of Hope have noted an increase in maturity with respect to M.P. over the years and the positive changes that appear to be in place which they believe are “substantial and genuine”.
He is described as being much more personable, engaged, participating in all programs he is involved in and a “role model to the other youth”. [ 98 ] He is noted to be more empathetic, involved with the staff, avoids negative situations, attempts to resolve issues between others when appropriate, and shows insight into his past and current behaviours.
The workers are of the view that M.P. is remorseful and has insight into his conduct and appreciates that his actions have impacted not only his own life but other lives as well. [ 99 ] The report notes while at Bluewater Youth Centre where he remained from October of 2010 to March 2012, when Bluewater was closed, he obtained the highest level of their behavioural system, notwithstanding there was an incident involving an altercation with another youth as well as the use of marijuana with another youth.
Overall, it appears his participation in groups dealing with substance abuse was appropriate and he was engaged in that program as with other programming. He not only attended programming but appears to have been an active participant. It was noted by one of his therapists at the facility that he was prepared to work on issues that challenged “old patterns of behaviour”. [ 100 ] The report sets out the plans of the young person. He indicates that his view of life has changed.
He notes the choices he made in 2010 will affect him the rest of his life as he indicated to the probation officer preparing the report and he is “now coming to terms that he must face what he did and the fear of what goes along with it”. His writings have improved dramatically to more positive subjects and his journal and poetry writing, the young person indicates, has evolved from “a very dark and morbid place to something of a hopeful inspiration”. M.P. is able to articulate his issues with substance abuse and how they played a role in his criminal activity.
He acknowledges that substances were used to enable him to not face “the reality of his depression and anger”. He now knows that he must and will connect with the appropriate professionals so he can cope with those issues as well as the issues relating to his stepfather. He hopes ultimately to complete a writer’s diploma at a college, while in custody if possible, and further that upon his release. [ 101 ] In her assessment and recommendations set out in the report Ms. Seremetkovski made a number of comments.
Those comments were adopted and elaborated upon during the course of her giving evidence and that evidence was consistent with the remarks contained in her pre-sentence report. In her pre-sentence report she notes as follows: “At the time of the offence, Matt’s circumstances were difficult. Although he was technically living at home with his mother and siblings, he was more often than not, staying at the home of the victim and Matt’s 35 year old girlfriend S.C..
While there for the good part of 6-8 months, M.P is reported to have engaged in excessive drinking and much substance abuse with his girlfriend and victim. As reported by M.P and his family, M.P struggled with depression, self cutting and was delving deeper and deeper into dark poetry with his girlfriend, fixating on negative feelings and events.
Given the aggravating and mitigating circumstances noted by family and those having worked with M.P., related to M.P, particularly, his level of maturity at the time of the offence and substance abuse; his ongoing struggles with unresolved anger and depression; the lack of value in life and the negative environment he surrounded himself in leading up [to] the murder, M.P is only now able to recognize how cloudy his judgment of reality was.
Those having worked with M.P while he has been in detention on a day to day basis, strongly believe that M.P. has made very positive changes in his outlook on life and is a good candidate to do well once released into the community with the appropriate supports in place. They have described M.P as a role model and one who does not get caught up in horseplay. He continues to maintain the highest level in his current placement and has developed mutually respectful relationships with the staff.
Staff are pleased in Matt’s successful efforts to make positive choices in his day to day interactions, and improve his own circumstances and self awareness. In reviewing Matthew’s written work during his transformation, there is a clear shift in Matt’s attitude. His writings have become more introspective and hopeful as opposed to dark, morbid and pessimistic. Over the course of his detention, this writer has met with M.P on numerous occasions to assist in his case management planning.
In addition to these formal gatherings whereby discussions were had on his behaviour and progress towards goals, this writer met with M.P. on 4 separate occasions, specifically for the purpose of this report. M.P. has demonstrated over time, his ability to assess the events that happened the evening of the offence and take responsibility and more importantly show remorse for his actions. He has been able to voice how not having resolved feelings towards his step father and turned to those willing to help him, led him to his current
predicament and he is very motivated to avoid these mistakes in the future. Matt’s plan is to complete a writer’s diploma at college while in custody if this is possible. Upon his release his plan is to move to northern Ontario with his family for a new start, away from old memories and previous influences. He hopes to connect to a program in his new area in which he will have ongoing support to deal with his feelings of remorse, and continuing to learn to let go of things he cannot control.
M.P. has acknowledged that the crime he committed led to the most serious of all possible consequences, namely, the death of the victim, but he is also cognizant of the irreparable harm he has done to the victim’s family. Over the course of nearly two and a half (2 ½) years in detention, he has thought about and taken increasingly more responsibility for his actions, and is trying to find ways to cope with the guilt that he feels he will carry for the rest of his life.
Matt’s history in the youth justice system prior to his most recent charge, was one of non-compliance however he was not involved in previous violent offences. As he has matured, M.P has shown respect for the rules of the facilities and respect for those supervising him.” (
b) Evidence After Remand: [ 102 ] The young person has now been in custody for just over three years since the date of his arrest. Filed as exhibits on the hearing of this application are copies of case management notes and daily logs from the facilities where M.P. has been held since his arrest. Those notes have been referred to extensively during the course of the hearing. The notes contain comments made during the course of case management meetings and otherwise, some of which the Crown argues are significant and relevant to the issue before the court.
In addition, witnesses were called from those facilities who have had day-to-day contact with M.P. while in custody at Ray of Hope (formerly Hope Manor) from March 2010 to October 2010 and most recently from March 6, 2012 to date. Evidence of Amy Stewart: [ 103 ] Ms. Stewart is a teacher at Ray of Hope and has had involvement with the young person M.P. in that capacity at that facility, initially in 2010 and, most recently, since his return to the facility in March of 2012. She teaches Grades 7 to 12.
The students that she teaches are in custody at the facility and are taught based on individual educational plans. [ 104 ] She described meeting M.P. in April of 2010. She described how the young person has progressed since that time and has earned a significant number of high school credits (soon to be 25). [ 105 ] Her first exposure in 2010 was while M.P. was taking Grade 9 and 10 courses. She indicated initially there was not a great deal of participation from the young person. He was withdrawn and emotional, crying on occasion during the first few weeks in custody.
M.P. eventually started to participate more and was never noted to be a behavioural concern in the classroom. She described him in 2010 as completing his work, being polite and respectful and working well. [ 106 ] She also spoke of the poetry that was in place in 2010.
She stated it was very dark, sad, devil and “those kind of things that were in the writings”. [ 107 ] She described how he was coming out of his shell a bit more in 2010 before he was transferred and noticed upon his return that he returned as a “mature, friendly, outgoing, very hardworking, determined, caring, responsible, empathetic individual” who was noted in all reports as a “role model for his peers”. She provided particulars of a number of incidents leading her to make those comments during the course of her evidence. [ 108 ] M.P.’s attitude is described as positive.
He consistently gives “one hundred percent effort every day”. He often forms positive relationships with his peers and offers to help those struggling within the program. His marks in the courses that he takes are well above average. [ 109 ] The witness specifically referred to M.P.’s writings since his return. During the course of her evidence she read some of those writings into the record. Those writings clearly indicate remorse for and insight into his past conduct. [ 110 ] In cross-examination it was put to Ms.
Stewart that while at Bluewater comments would seem to have indicated that M.P. was making “very slow progress and not very academically able in some classes”. When asked about that particular issue, Ms. Stewart indicated that that did not “shock me at all” as M.P. does work slowly and is very methodical. The witness also pointed out the comments that she had from Bluewater with respect to M.P. were that M.P.’s effort in the courses have been “outstanding. Excellent classroom demeanour, co-operative, thorough in all assignments, very pleasant in class, good application in subject material”.
Evidence of Daniel Martinez: [ 111 ] Mr. Martinez was M.P.’s primary worker at Ray of Hope during his initial stay there and has been as well since the young person’s return in March of 2012. [ 112 ] Mr. Martinez spoke generally of the evolution of the young person during his contact with him. He described him in 2010 as initially being withdrawn and difficult to deal with. M.P. progressed, however, while at Hope Manor initially, advancing to Level 4, the second highest level obtainable by a youth in that facility.
During the initial period, notwithstanding some progress, there were occasions when M.P. was disrespectful or argumentative with staff and that was acknowledged by the witness. M.P. required some coaching and encouragement from the staff and his progress together with some concerns are noted in the case management reports and daily logs marked as exhibits in this matter. [ 113 ] Upon M.P.’s return to Ray of Hope in 2012 Mr. Martinez noted that he was “totally different”.
While at Bluewater he had been able to achieve the highest behavioural level and as of the date of giving evidence M.P. had advanced to the highest level now at
Ray of Hope. [ 114 ] Mr. Martinez described M.P. when he returned from Bluewater as being “very mature, very respectful, very compliant”. He was more sociable, non-confrontational and helpful to peers who were having difficulty. Not only was he more pro-active with his own peers in assisting them, he was also assisting staff in programming. [ 115 ] With respect to the programming in the facility, M.P. presented as positive and helped other peers become involved. He took
part in virtually every program offered within the institution including programming involved with character building, anger awareness, substance abuse and chapel. [ 116 ] M.P.’s performance upon his return in March of 2012 was very positive, although there were some incidents of negative behaviours. In May of 2012 the young person apparently was signing on for video games using inappropriate terminology given why he was in custody and in September 2012 M.P. apparently indicated something to the effect “If I saw the person that did something to my sister I would do what I did to get in here again”.
Those entries are found in daily logs but apparently not considered significant enough to be discussed at case management meetings. According to the Crown this indicates a lack of response from the youth facility and should cause the court concern with respect to the credibility and/or reliability of the staff when speaking about M.P. generally.
The court ultimately finds no merit in that position initially and particularly after hearing from both psychiatrists who place no great weight on those particular incidents. [ 117 ] With respect to the incident involving the name adopted during the video game, “Happy Killa Man”, staff spoke to M.P. about that and he removed the name from the game understanding that it was not appropriate. [ 118 ] Mr. Martinez was cross-examined thoroughly and taken through a number of daily logs.
He was referred to comments within the logs made by various staff members on occasion but, clearly, M.P.’s conduct while at Ray of Hope, particularly since his return in March of 2012 has been, perhaps although not exemplary, very positive and M.P. since his return is much more mature and takes on more responsibility. He has progressed to the highest level of behavioural achievement at Ray of Hope and seems to show respect for the staff as does the staff for him. Evidence of Evan Garst: [ 119 ] Mr. Garst is the chaplain at Ray of Hope secure facility and has been for the past 12 months.
Prior to that he also worked at Hope Manor (formerly Ray of Hope) as a youth care worker and shift supervisor. [ 120 ] His involvement with the young person began with a spiritual assessment evaluation. M.P. has expressed interest in faith and spirituality and regularly attends at chapel programs offered within the facility. Volunteer speakers attend to speak to the young persons and M.P. is a regular attendee. He takes
part in the groups in a positive way, on occasion redirecting his peers who might be behaving negatively. [ 121 ] The witness described M.P. as respectful of volunteers and staff that participate in the programs and an attentive participant. This witness relayed to the court an incident where M.P. transferred to another unit within the institution to assist staff in meeting challenges with respect to two other residents.
M.P. apparently showed a significant amount of maturity and responsibility on the unit that he was transferred to. [ 122 ] This witness spoke of M.P.’s ability to “adjust and co-operate and understand”. He could not report any negative behaviour from his involvement with the young person. (
c) Psychiatric Evidence: Evidence of Mark Pearce: [ 123 ] Pursuant to s. 34 of the Y.C.J.A. a psychiatric assessment was ordered by the court with the consent of the young person. That assessment was carried out by Dr. Pearce and his report which is dated September 10, 2012 is marked as Exhibit #1 on this application. Dr. Pearce also gave evidence during the hearing. [ 124 ] There is no issue taken with the qualifications of Dr. Pearce by counsel and he is certainly more than capable, as is Dr. Gojer, to provide expert evidence. The report of Dr. Pearce is thorough and comprehensive. Dr.
Pearce had an opportunity to meet with the young person on one occasion, on June 6, 2012, and conducted an interview that lasted apparently three and a half hours. He also had an opportunity to review various material including the statement of facts, past medical records involving M.P. as well as the records that existed at that time from both Bluewater and Hope Manor. In addition, Dr. Pearce was able to obtain information directly from collateral sources including the mother and M.P.’s former girlfriend. [ 125 ] With respect to the detention records, at the time of the preparation of the report Dr.
Pearce had reviewed the records that existed up to that point from both Bluewater and Hope Manor. He had noted positive comments contained within those reports but also noted the incidents initially at Hope Manor involving at least one physical altercation with another youth and a similar incident when he was initially transferred to Bluewater in October of 2010. There were also incidents involving the use of marijuana apparently with another youth in 2011. Dr.
Pearce was also questioned with regard to incidents that the Crown referred to as being of “serious concern” in May and September of 2012 upon M.P.’s return to Ray of Hope. [ 126 ] Dr. Pearce was of the view it was not clear that M.P. suffered from a major mental illness such as major depressive disorder as opined by Dr. Graham when M.P. was first brought into custody. Dr. Pearce noted initially M.P. experienced a low mood following his incarceration and had been abusing substances leading up to the event. He had also been struggling to control his temper but Dr.
Pearce found it unclear if M.P. was clinically depressed. He favoured a diagnosis of adjustment disorder with depressed mood initially following incarceration. He was also of the view that M.P. may have met the criteria for a substance-induced mood disorder but opined that the most appropriate diagnosis was polysubstance abuse.
[ 127 ] Both Dr. Pearce and Dr. Gojer were ad idem in opining that M.P. met the criteria for a diagnosis of conduct disorder, childhood onset, of moderate severity. [ 128 ] Dr. Pearce noted the lack of motivation of M.P. prior to the event which he acknowledges may have been due to substance abuse. He also referred to the relationship with S.C. as dysfunctional as she was much older than M.P. and suffered from schizophrenia and substance abuse issues.
The doctor referred to M.P. as struggling initially while in a custodial setting but did note that up to the preparation of his report in September of 2012 there had been a suggestion that M.P. had matured over the preceding six months and taken more responsibility for his actions. At the time of giving evidence at the hearing a further period of time had elapsed and Dr. Pearce had reviewed updated records from Ray of Hope. The doctor indicated that as of the date of his evidence there had been some 13 to 14 months of positive gains with respect to M.P. [ 129 ] Dr.
Pearce did not diagnose a personality disorder, although maladaptive anti-social and borderline personality traits are evident. The doctor notes at pg. 29 that: “In conclusion, M. P. has historically suffered from an adjustment disorder with depressed mood. I cannot exclude the possibility that he may have met criteria for major depressive disorder. He has abused alcohol, cannabis and possibly cocaine. Finally, he was conduct disordered and he continues to possess maladaptive antisocial and borderline personality traits.” [ 130 ] Testing was conducted by Dr. Pearce using actuarial methods of risk assessment.
Using the Violence Risk Appraisal Guide (VRAG) and the Psychopathy Checklist – Revised (PCL-
R) the doctor indicated at pg. 31 of his report as follows: “In risk assessment, one of the best predictors of recidivism is an individual’s
[…]
Loading document…