R. v. Mudryk, 2013 ONCJ 465
Opinion
ONTARIO COURT OF JUSTICE DATE: 2013·08∙12 COURT FILE No.: Halton 2584/11 Citation: R. v. Mudryk , 2013 ONCJ 465 BETWEEN: HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN — AND — MARYAN MUDRYK Before Justice F.L. FORSYTH Heard on August 22, August 23, August 29, August 30, December 12, December 18, 2012 and April 3, 2013. Oral verdicts of guilty rendered on June 10/13 Written reasons for Judgment released on August 12, 2013 Monica Mackenzie ................................................................................. Counsel for the Crown Ernst Ashurov ....................................................... Counsel for the defendant Maryan Mudryk FORSYTH J.:
Summary of Evidence at Trial [ 1 ] Mr. Mudryk was charged with one count of operating his motor vehicle while his ability to do so was impaired by alcohol, contrary to s. 253(1) (
a) of the Criminal Code and also with a count of having a blood alcohol concentration in excess of 80 milligrams of alcohol in 100 millilitres of blood while operating his motor vehicle, contrary to s. 253(1)(
b) of the Criminal Code. Both charges arose out of an incident on August 11, 2011. He retained Mr. Ashurov on these charges and after the Crown elected to proceed summarily on both counts on August 22, 2012 he entered a plea of not guilty to both charges. [ 2 ] At the outset of the trial there was an order excluding witnesses with no exceptions and it was agreed by both Crown and defence counsel that the matter would be conducted as a blended trial and ss. 8, 9, 10(
b) and 24(2) Charter application. In addition, both counsel informed the Court that there would be a s. 7 Charter application and a voluntariness voir dire required with respect to utterances made by Mr. Mudryk to the investigating officers. [ 3 ] The first witness called by the Crown was Zvonimir Pejakovic. Mr. Pejakovic testified in Chief that on August 11, 2011 he had been driving northbound on Sutton Drive in the City of Burlington toward a stop light at the intersection of Sutton Drive and Dundas Highway.
He came to a stop at his red light at the intersection and was waiting for a dump truck that was proceeding eastbound from his left to pass by before he turned right to travel eastbound on Dundas Highway as well. While waiting there he noticed a minivan stopped on the other side of Dundas facing westbound at the intersection of Sutton and Dundas. It appeared to be waiting to make a left-hand turn to travel southbound on Sutton. [ 4 ] He noticed the van begin to slowly make a left turn and at the same time he heard the sound of brakes being applied coming from the truck to his left.
He said that the dump truck collided with the turning minivan while the traffic light for both the van and the truck was yellow at that time. As a result of this collision he said that the van was driven into a highway light standard pole. He said that he believed that the truck had hit its brakes just as the van began to make its left-hand turn in front of the truck. [ 5 ] Mr. Pejakovic said that as soon as the collision had occurred he got out of his vehicle and ran over to the van and gave the
driver a bottle of water. He noticed that the driver was trapped in the driver’s seat but he said that the driver was able to open the water bottle. There is no issue on this trial that the driver was the accused, Mr. Mudryk. Mr. Pejakovic said that his wife called the police and about 10 minutes later a first responder appeared on the scene and it was a fire truck. [ 6 ] He said that he had walked away from the driver as soon as he had given him the water bottle, but he noticed that some others did try to comfort him.
He said that he had not observed any alcoholic beverages in the van when he gave the water bottle to the accused. [ 7 ] He said that he had asked the accused if he was okay and the accused responded, saying that he was, but, in Mr. Pejakovic’s opinion, he looked shocked and scared. [ 8 ] He said that he had gone around to the back of the van to see if he could remove some items from the back to help get the accused out of the van, but he was unable to do so other than the fact that he took some cables and other materials out of the van.
He did not recall any particular company logo on the van. [ 9 ] In cross-examination he said that the collision had occurred at about 2:00 p.m. His wife was sitting next to him in their car. The light for him at Sutton and Dundas was green as he approached. He said that the truck had been travelling fast downhill at about 60 kilometres per hour, in his opinion. He also said that the speed limit at that point was 60 kilometres an hour.
He agreed with the suggestion that it would be legal to make a left-hand turn on a yellow traffic light. [ 10 ] He said that he had spoken to an officer at the scene and given a formal statement to P.C. Urie in February of 2012. Mr.
Ashurov showed him two statements and he identified each of them and said that he had read them before giving evidence. [ 11 ] He was referred to his August 11, 2011 statement which was in writing and he agreed that he had told the police that the truck had been travelling at full speed and he meant by that phrase not slowing down for the yellow light and going about 60 kilometres an hour at the time when it entered the intersection. He said that he agreed that he had told the police that the truck was going “very, I’m telling you, fast” down the hill at 60 kilometres per hour or more.
He said that it certainly seemed very fast for a dump truck. [ 12 ] He then testified that he thought that the truck was about 20 feet from the intersection when the van began its left-hand turn in front of him. However, he agreed when shown his police statement that he had told the police that the truck was about 150 feet or so from the intersection and he had said that the truck should have been able to see the van and slow down for the van to make its turn. He had also said that the truck was coming down hard and the intersection was clear for the van.
This statement was given about 1½ hours after the actual collision on August 11, he said. [ 13 ] Mr. Ashurov referred him to some interaction between him and the investigating officer at the scene of the collision. He said that the officer had asked him to exit his vehicle and wait some distance away for another officer to take his statement. [ 14 ] He said that, in his own opinion, the truck could have slowed down or the van could have executed its left-hand turn faster instead of moving so slowly. [ 15 ] Mr. Ashurov referred him then to his February 26, 2012 second police statement.
He explained that the second statement had come about because his wife had told him that P.C. Urie had called the house and said that the accused person was now saying that someone had given him some alcoholic beverage to drink. Therefore, he said that his wife told him that he should write out a statement of exactly what he had done at the scene, especially with respect to what he had given the accused to drink. Therefore, Mr. Pejakovic said that he wrote a statement out and included in it the fact that he had given the accused a water bottle.
This information, he agreed, was not included in his August 11, 2011 statement. He pointed out that in his August 11 statement he did tell the officer that he had asked the accused if he wanted water but that he received no answer. At this point in his cross-examination he said he was 100 per cent sure, however, that he had told a female officer that he had given the accused a bottle of water. He did not know why that officer, if he had done so, did not write it down in his statement and he did not recall whether he had read his statement before he signed it.
This answer referred to his August 11 statement. [ 16 ] With respect to his February 26, 2012 statement he said that he had given the driver a bottle of Nestle’s water because 99 per cent of the time he and his wife buy that brand of water. [ 17 ] He agreed that of course he did not see what the driver was doing after he walked away from the van. [ 18 ] He said that it took a good hour for the fire department personnel to extricate the accused from the van and he could not really see what they were doing to accomplish that rescue.
He said that nobody was standing right beside the driver’s door watching the accused as far as he could recall. [ 19 ] In re-examination he told the Crown that rescuers were working right around the van, however. He said that the intersection was clear and, as he had said in his police statement, no other vehicles were in the intersection. [ 20 ] At this point Mr. Ashurov asked leave of the Court to continue his cross-examination. The Crown consented and I agreed. [ 21 ] Mr. Pejakovic told Mr.
Ashurov that the bottle of Nestle’s water that he had given the accused had a blue and white label on it and the words “Pure Life”. Mr. Ashurov then showed him a photograph of a water bottle that was sitting inside the driver’s compartment of the accused’s minivan in the photo. Mr. Pejakovic said that what he was looking at in the photograph was certainly not the water bottle that he had given to the accused from all appearances.
On consent, photographs of the driver’s compartment of the accused’s van showing a plastic bottle in the compartment were entered as Exhibits 2A and 2B. [ 22 ] The next witness was Bita Pejakovic who testified in Chief that she is the wife of the first witness and that she was a passenger at the time in her husband’s vehicle. Asked for a recitation of her observations of the events that led up to the collision, she gave a very similar account to that of her husband. She concluded by saying that when the light was yellow for eastbound and
westbound traffic on Dundas the van began its left-hand turn and the dump truck collided with it in the intersection. [ 23 ] She said that she had seen some people removing what looked to her like some Bell Canada equipment from the rear of the accused’s van. [ 24 ] She said that her husband had given one bottle of Nestle’s Pure Life water from their vehicle to the driver. She explained that she always buys that brand of water. [ 25 ] She said that the truck had been approaching the intersection at a fast rate of speed.
She said that she called 911 herself and the operator hung up in the middle of her call and she was not sure how long she had been on the phone with the operator. [ 26 ] Mr. Ashurov began his cross-examination, but it was interrupted due to the fact that the 911 call CD could not be located to assist him in cross-examining Mrs. Pejakovic. Therefore, his cross-examination was mainly postponed to the next day, August 23, 2012. [ 27 ] The Crown then called Kelly Hassall who testified in Chief that she was driving westbound on Number 5 or Dundas Highway at the time.
She stopped her vehicle at the intersection of Dundas and Sutton because her traffic light was yellow. She described the highway as having two driving lanes and a left-hand turn lane at that intersection for westbound traffic. Her cousin was in the passenger seat. She turned to look at her infant son who was in the back seat when the light turned red and, as she did so, she heard her cousin gasp. She therefore turned back and observed the dump truck colliding with a van which then struck the light standard pole.
She turned her vehicle to the right and got it off of the travelled portion of the roadway and called 911. She estimated that this call was not more than a minute after the collision.
About five minutes later, rescue vehicles arrived. [ 28 ] She said that there had been no vehicle in front of her when she stopped her own vehicle at the yellow light, but she said that there may have been a vehicle to the left of her in the left-hand turn lane, although she was not 100 per cent sure. [ 29 ] She said that she had absolutely no interaction with the drivers of either the dump truck or the van. [ 30 ] In cross-examination she agreed that her five-minute estimate of the time that it took for the first rescue vehicle to arrive was exactly that, an estimate. [ 31 ] The next witness called by the Crown was Andrea Machry who testified in Chief that she had been driving eastbound on Dundas Highway towards the Sutton intersection in one of the two driving lanes.
As she was behind a large dump truck in the right- hand lane, she moved into the left-hand lane in order to pass the dump truck, but she was still about 50 metres or so to the rear of it when she noticed the light turning yellow for eastbound traffic at Sutton. Therefore, she braked her own vehicle and slowed down for the yellow light. She said that the dump truck did not seem to slow down or brake at all.
She estimated that both she and the truck had been travelling at approximately 60 kilometres per hour. [ 32 ] She said that she then noticed a van begin to make a left-hand turn from the westbound driving lanes of Dundas and at that point the dump truck braked but struck the van on the passenger side in the intersection.
The impact caused the van to be driven into the light standard pole on the south-east corner of the intersection and the pole fell to the pavement with part of it being on and under the van. [ 33 ] She said that she immediately called 911 and less than a minute later she had exited her vehicle and spoken to the driver of the van, who would be the accused, and told him she had called the police and not to worry. She asked him if he was okay. She said that she was talking to him while she was on the 911 call and walking.
She said that he seemed stunned and was blinking and staring straight ahead. [ 34 ] She said that she then helped others remove some boxes from the interior of the rear of the van out of it. [ 35 ] She said that she had stood about three feet away from the driver’s door when she was asking him about his condition. She said that she saw the driver drinking from a water bottle.
She said that she did not see or recognize any beverage containers that looked as if they would be alcoholic beverage containers. [ 36 ] She said that she had seen the dump truck brake lights come on just as the van began to make its turn in front of the truck. [ 37 ] In cross-examination she said that she believed that one of the ladies she had seen in court on the day when she testified had been standing beside the van driver’s door, but it was not the previous witness, Ms.
Hassall. [ 38 ] She agreed that in her police statement given at the scene she had told the officer that the dump truck had no “intention” of slowing down, in her opinion. [ 39 ] She agreed that on March 6 th , 2012 P.C. Urie had asked her for a second statement, particularly because he wanted to know if she had noticed any alcohol beverages in the van at the time. Mr. Ashurov produced both her August 11, 2011 statement and her March 6, 2012 statement to her. She agreed that her memory of the events would be better, of course, on August 11, 2011 than on March 6, 2012. [ 40 ] She agreed that P.C.
Urie had told her that the van driver had been charged with impaired driving. She agreed that March 6, 2012 was the first time she had even tried to remember whether or not the driver had a water bottle in his hands. She agreed that at the scene of the collision when she stood at the driver’s door she did not notice any odour of alcohol coming from the vehicle. [ 41 ] She agreed that the bottle that she is calling a water bottle “looked like” a plastic water bottle, perhaps of the 500 mL size, and then she said that it appeared to be small. When Mr.
Ashurov questioned her about the seemingly uncertain phrase “looked like”, she said that did not mean that she was not sure because when she was testifying in court on August 23 she was quite confident to say that it was a plastic bottle, but she just can’t be certain of the contents of it.
[ 42 ] After she identified her voice on her 911 call tape, Mr. Ashurov played the 911 call in court for her. Upon its conclusion, she agreed with his suggestion that there was a pause after she asked how the occupants of the van were doing and that voices seemed to answer but she agreed that the voices sounded far away. Therefore, she was prepared to agree with Mr. Ashurov that she could not have been speaking to the driver, the accused, at that moment.
On consent, this 911 CD became Exhibit Number 3 in this trial. [ 43 ] Of course she again agreed that her memory would not have been as good with respect to details of the event when she was being questioned by P.C.
Urie on March 6, 2012 as it would have been on August 11, 2011. [ 44 ] She said that today she could say that she recalled the accused drinking from a water bottle, but she agreed that she had not recalled that fact during any of the times when she thought about the matter since August 11, 2011. [ 45 ] Finally, she said that she did not see any alcoholic containers lying around the van. [ 46 ] In re-examination she told the Crown that she believed that she had spoken with the driver at least once and maybe a second time when she returned to the driver’s door of the van. [ 47 ] The next witness called by the Crown was Travis Marrs who testified in Chief that he was driving in the left-hand turn lane at Number 5 Dundas Highway and Sutton intersection behind the van.
He said that when the van was about 100 yards in front of him it began to turn left on the yellow light which, in his estimation, was about to turn red. He saw the dump truck coming eastbound at what he estimated to be 80 to 90 kilometres per hour and he said that it did not brake until it was almost at the stop line of the intersection in the eastbound right lane.
He said that the van had already begun its turn by that time and it was struck by the truck and driven into the light standard pole on the south-east corner. [ 48 ] He called 911 and exited his vehicle and walked over to the van and spoke to the driver, the accused, to determine if he was all right. He said that he determined that the accused was okay and he said that he also noticed a woman standing around there too and he described what both counsel agreed would seem to have been Mrs.
Pejakovic. [ 49 ] He said that the accused was pinned in the driver’s compartment and had nowhere to go, although he was able to move his arms. He was trying to move his legs, but to no avail. [ 50 ] He said that he did not observe any beverages inside the van and he helped others to empty the back of the van. [ 51 ] He said that when the responders arrived they asked him to stand back from the scene, and of course he complied. [ 52 ] In cross-examination he said that he had stuck his head right up to the driver’s window on the van when he was checking on the accused.
He estimated that his own head would have been about three feet from the accused’s head and he had asked the accused if he wanted him to call anyone, but the accused did not take him up on that. In this position and this distance from the accused’s head, he said he did not smell any alcohol coming from the vehicle. [ 53 ] He said that the accused had no speech problems, although he appeared to be shocked.
He said he did not see the driver drink anything at all while in his presence and he did not see any containers that would have reminded him of alcoholic beverages when he was helping others empty out the back of the van. [ 54 ] Once again, Mr. Ashurov produced what turned out to be a second statement of this witness given to P.C. Urie in March 2012. He said that P.C.
Urie had called him and told him that the accused was now trying to get his charges dropped because he had either consumed alcohol just before or just after the collision and before the first responders arrived. [ 55 ] He was shown Exhibit 2A and 2B which were the photographs of a plastic bottle in the driver’s compartment. He said, however, that he had not noticed that bottle at the time. [ 56 ] Mr.
Ashurov introduced through this witness Exhibit 4A which depicted scattered items from the interior of the van on the ground outside according to the witness. 4B, he agreed, was simply a close-up of 4A. 4C appeared to be a beer can, a hammer and a battery pack, he said. [ 57 ] In re-examination, the Crown showed him Exhibit 4A which appeared to contain a seat from the van and Mr. Marrs said that he had not removed the seat, nor had he touched it at the time.
Shown 4C he also said that he never handled the items depicted in 4C. [ 58 ] After this witness the Crown called back Bita Pejakovic for cross-examination by Mr. Ashurov. She was referred to her August 11, 2011 police statement and in that statement she had told the police that the truck had run the yellow light and that she would have stopped had she been driving the truck. She expressed the opinion that vehicles often run the red light at that particular intersection.
She said that the truck, in her opinion, had been travelling faster than 60 kilometres per hour. [ 59 ] She said that her husband had told her that he was going to take a bottle of water over to the driver from their cooler in their vehicle and that is what he did. She said that she had never left their vehicle. She also said that her husband never ever went to the back of the van. [ 60 ] Mr. Ashurov then played her 911 call and my own observation was that she was very obviously upset while she was reporting the accident to the police. [ 61 ] With respect to P.C.
Urie calling her on February 12, 2011 she said that he had told her that he needed a second statement from her husband. She said that the officer never told her that the accused was trying to say that he had consumed alcohol after the accident, however. On consent, her 911 call was entered as Exhibit Number 5 in this trial. [ 62 ] She agreed that she had not mentioned the fact that her husband had given the accused a water bottle in her statement to the
police and she pointed out that she was not asked about it on August 11, 2011. Therefore, February 12, 2011 is the first time that she had told anybody about the water bottle. [ 63 ] She said that she wrote out her husband’s February 12, 2011 statement to P.C. Urie for him because her husband does not write well in English. [ 64 ] In re-examination, the Crown introduced as Exhibit Number 6 a photograph of her own vehicle and the position in which it was parked at the collision scene. [ 65 ] The next witness called by the Crown was P.C.
Mark Urie who testified in Chief that he has been a Halton Regional Police Constable since 2003. He was on uniform patrol on August 11, 2011 and at 2:48 p.m. he was dispatched to the intersection of Sutton Drive and Number 5 Dundas Highway.
His notes and a will-say statement that he had prepared were qualified and he was permitted to refresh his memory from them during his testimony. [ 66 ] He said that when he arrived at the scene about 2:50 p.m. he found the minivan driver trapped in the driver’s compartment of the vehicle where it was sitting at rest having collided with the light standard pole on the south-east corner of the intersection.
He believed that he was the first responder to arrive and he believed that the collision had occurred immediately before the dispatch time of 2:48 p.m. [ 67 ] He said that the speed limit at that intersection was 80 kilometres per hour on Dundas Highway on August 11, 2011, but in the spring of 2012 it was reduced to 60 kilometres per hour. [ 68 ] The Crown directed him to his observations at the scene of the collision. He said that a couple of people were standing nearby the driver’s door of the van when he arrived. He observed very severe damage to the passenger side of the van.
He said that the front of the dump truck was actually protruding into the passenger side interior of the van. The lower portion of the light standard which had been knocked down was actually lying underneath the driver’s seat. [ 69 ] He checked out the condition of the dump truck driver and determined that he was all right. He then checked out the accused, who was the driver of the van, and before doing so he asked people who were standing around the van to move back for safety reasons because the light standard could actually end up falling further and might strike them.
It was totally bent out of shape, he said. [ 70 ] When he approached the accused in the driver’s seat he asked him if he was okay and the accused said that he was. He said the accused told him that he was just pinned and also that there were no other passengers in the vehicle to be concerned about. He observed that the accused’s eyes were glossy and red and he detected a strong odour, which he attributed to the deployed airbag on the driver’s side of the van.
He also said that he observed extensive damage to the interior of the driver’s compartment and that the driver’s door was bent into a “U” shape. [ 71 ] He said that the accused seemed to be able to move his arms freely and he had a plastic bottle of water in one hand in which there was still some liquid. He opined that the accused would have had limited ability to access other areas of the van besides the driver’s compartment.
He said that he did not see any alcoholic beverages in the driver’s compartment or in the front passenger area or the rear passenger area. [ 72 ] He stayed with the accused for a minute or so before the arrival of EMS and fire department personnel. He then decided to speak to some of the witnesses who were standing around the scene. From them he concluded that the dump truck had struck the van which was turning left at the yellow light while the dump truck drove into the intersection on the yellow light.
He said that this opinion was consistent with the resting point of the two vehicles and the visible damage. [ 73 ] He said that it took an hour to extricate the accused from the driver’s compartment and he watched the process. While this was happening he saw alcoholic beverage containers being emptied out of the van by the rear of the van and placed on the ground. Amongst these items he said that he noticed a glass bottle of Silent Sam vodka, 1.4 litres in size. He said that this bottle was empty but its cap was on. He also noticed a plastic battle of Polar Ice vodka, 10-ounce size, empty as well.
There was also a crushed beer can and also a mouthwash bottle with liquid in it. [ 74 ] The Crown introduced as Exhibit Number 7 through the officer a bag with alcohol beverage containers which the officer described as one Laker Ice beer can, crushed, 5.5 per cent alcohol strength, a second Laker Ice beer can crushed at 5.5 per cent alcohol strength, a Banff Ice Vodka bottle, 375 millilitres in volume, a can of Lakeport Pilsner beer at 5 per cent alcohol strength, crushed, a glass bottle of Silent Sam vodka, 40 per cent alcohol strength, 750 millilitres, empty and damaged on one side. [ 75 ] When asked about his earlier description of a plastic Polar Ice vodka bottle, he said that he believed that he made a mistake and mistook the Banff Ice vodka bottle for a Polar Ice vodka bottle. [ 76 ] He said that the accused certainly did not consume any alcoholic beverage while he, P.C.
Urie, was watching him. [ 77 ] The Crown referred him to an interaction that he had with the accused while the accused was inside the ambulance at the scene. He said that he then noticed a strong odour of an alcoholic beverage emanating from the accused’s mouth. He asked him if he had been drinking that day and the accused answered “one beer, 10:00 a.m.”. [ 78 ] At 3:45 p.m. P.C. Urie said that he had formed his opinion that the accused had operated his motor vehicle while his ability to do so had been impaired by alcohol and he, therefore, arrested him on a charge pursuant to s. 253(1) (
a) of the Criminal Code . [ 79 ] At 3:50 p.m. he provided the accused his rights to counsel and when asked if he understood them he said the accused said “yes”, but at that time he declined the opportunity to speak to a lawyer by saying, “Not right now”. At 3:51 he provided the standard caution to the accused and Mr. Mudryk said that he did understand that caution. At 3:52 he made a demand for samples of the accused’s breath pursuant to s. 254(3) of the Code and when asked if he understood the accused said, “Yes, I do”.
[ 80 ] The Crown asked the officer to recite his reasonable and probable grounds for his arrest and he said that he included in that opinion the information he had received about the physical appearance of the collision scene, as well as information received from eyewitnesses to the collision, as well as his observations of the accused’s red, glossy eyes and the alcohol containers that were found in the vehicle.
He also said that the accused’s response of having had one drink at 10:00 a.m., plus the existing odour of alcohol on his breath, had also contributed to the formation of his opinion. [ 81 ] At 3:51 p.m. he said that the ambulance left with the accused for Joseph Brant Hospital in Burlington and he called in a request for a qualified Intoxilyzer technician to be sent to the hospital. He himself rode to the hospital with the accused in the ambulance.
Once arriving at Joseph Brant Hospital the accused was assessed by the hospital personnel. [ 82 ] At 4:28 p.m. he provided the accused with his rights to counsel again before the first breath test was going to be administered, but the accused again declined to exercise that right. [ 83 ] At 4:38 p.m. he said that P.C. Caron arrived at the hospital with an Intoxilyzer 8000C. P.C. Caron was the qualified Intoxilyzer technician. He said that Mr. Mudryk was then brought into Trauma Room A in the hospital and placed on the bed in that room. P.C.
Urie then testified that he completed his Intoxilyzer information sheet and gave it to P.C. Caron and that the contents were virtually the same as the evidence that he had just given viva voce about his RPG for the arrest of the accused on the s. 253(1) (
a) charge. [ 84 ] He said that at 5:02 p.m. he turned the accused over to P.C. Caron and he remained in the presence of Caron and the accused for the breath tests. [ 85 ] At 5:38 p.m. he said that the accused was returned to his custody with the results of the Intoxilyzer tests. After hearing about the readings, he said that he then charged the accused with one count pursuant to s. 253(1) (
b) of the Criminal Code and turned the custody of the accused over to another officer. [ 86 ] He said that the next day, on August 12 th , he had received some information from the accused’s wife. [ 87 ] In cross-examination P.C. Urie said that he had been a qualified Intoxilyzer technician since 2007. He said that he had prepared a will-say statement on or after August 11, 2011. In early February 2012 Charon Kerr from the Crown’s office requested more information from witnesses and from him with respect to the evidence, if any, of the accused having the ability to access alcoholic beverages after the collision.
He said that Ms. Kerr told him that alcohol consumption by the accused after the collision had been raised at the judicial pre-trial by Mr. Ashurov. Therefore, the officer said that he spoke to the witnesses Machry, Marrs and Mr. Pejakovic. He said that he also spoke to other persons whom he believed had not been in a position to observe such alleged activity by the accused, but nevertheless he felt he should speak to them. [ 88 ] He agreed that his reference to the accused having a water bottle in his hand in the vehicle when he observed him is not in his August 11, 2011 statement.
Nor was it in his notes that he prepared while investigating the collision or in his will-say statement. It is only in his supplementary will say statement that he has made reference to that observation and he prepared that supplementary statement after Ms. Kerr had asked him to try to recall any other details. Therefore, he seemed to be testifying that the reference to the accused having a water bottle occurred to him as an afterthought after he was prompted to try to search his memory for further details by Ms.
Kerr. [ 89 ] With respect to his reference in his February 2012 will-say statement to the water bottle being given to the accused by a witness, he said that he knows that one of the witnesses had told him that that had occurred, but he could not say which one. [ 90 ] He agreed that in his February 2012 statement he had said that he had looked carefully inside the accused’s van and did not see any alcoholic beverage containers visible at that time. He said that he did not see any such containers until about 20 minutes before Mr.
Mudryk was extricated from his pinned position in the driver’s seat, and the ones that he did see were in the rear passenger area. He explained that he had been standing at the back of the van with the hatch raised up when he made this observation. He said that he had observed the fire department personnel as they found these containers on the floor of the van when the seats were being removed from the van as part of their attempt to extricate the accused.
He agreed with the suggestion that these containers could have been in the van for a long time for all he knew. [ 91 ] He agreed that the air bag deployment had left an overwhelming odour in the vehicle, but he denied being able to detect the odour of any gasoline or antifreeze. [ 92 ] With respect to the speech pattern of the accused when he was dealing with him, he said that Mr. Mudryk’s speech was not slurred and that it was simply noticeably accented. [ 93 ] He said that he had no recollection of the dump truck driver telling him that he had entered the intersection on a green light.
Nor did he have any recollection of Ms. Hassall telling him that the dump truck had driven through a red light. [ 94 ] Mr. Ashurov then questioned him about the physical symptoms that he had noticed about Mr. Mudryk at the scene. The officer agreed that the red glossy eyes could be consistent with acid vapours released from the airbag explosion and also the trauma of a serious collision. [ 95 ] He maintained that he had kept an eye on the driver’s seat of the van even when he was talking to witnesses some distance away.
He agreed that in his August 11, 2011 notes he had noted that he had close contact with the scene as opposed to close contact with the accused, the driver. He said that he meant the same thing on each occasion when he had referred to this evidence and that was that he had not had “involved contact” with the accused at the scene. [ 96 ] He agreed with the suggestion that the extreme odour of alcohol that he had noticed in the ambulance coming from the accused’s breath could mean recent consumption of alcoholic beverages by the accused.
[ 97 ] He said that he did believe that the collision had occurred at approximately 2:45 p.m. and he had no trouble agreeing that if the accused had only had one beer at 10:00 a.m. the alcohol from that beer would have been eliminated from the accused’s system by 2:45 p.m. [ 98 ] For what it’s worth he agreed with Mr.
Ashurov that he had conducted an investigation into numerous “T-bone” motor vehicle collisions which did not necessarily involve a driver who had been impaired by alcohol in the vehicle that had struck another vehicle broadside. [ 99 ] The cross-examination was then interrupted by the end of the court day and the matter was remanded for continuation to August 29, 2012. On that day Mr. Ashurov continued the cross-examination of P.C. Urie. [ 100 ] The officer said that he had charged the driver of the dump truck with Highway Traffic Act offences involving an alleged misalignment of his rear brakes.
He said that the Dundas Highway road surface at the time in the area of the collision was wet from water sprinklers at the roadside, but he did not know whether this had affected the truck’s ability to stop in time to avoid a collision. [ 101 ] He said that he had no idea whether medications had been given to Mr. Mudryk at the hospital before he provided his breath tests. He was aware of the fact that he had been diagnosed with a broken arm and broken ribs, a punctured lung and a fractured vertebra. He said that as far as he knew, Mr.
Mudryk weighed 80 kilograms at the time or 176 pounds. [ 102 ] In re-examination he said that he had noted the posted speed limit of 80 kilometres an hour in the area of the collision. [ 103 ] He also said that the formation of his RPG for the arrest on the 253(
a) count had been distilled from a constellation of factors and symptoms available to him. [ 104 ] Mr. Ashurov once again asked leave of the Court to pose an additional cross-examination question to the officer. The Crown did not object and he was allowed to do so. The officer told Mr. Ashurov that Mr. Mudryk himself had told him that his body weight was 80 kilograms. [ 105 ] The next witness called by the Crown was P.C. David Caron who testified in Chief that he is a Halton Regional Police Service officer and also a qualified Intoxilyzer 8000C technician.
He was dispatched to the Joseph Brant Hospital on the day in question to conduct breath tests on Mr. Mudryk. He arrived at 2:38 p.m. and brought an Intoxilyzer 8000C with him from the station. He met with P.C. Urie who gave him his RPG. He said that at 4:47 p.m. he formed the opinion that Mr. Mudryk was impaired.
He provided him with his rights to counsel, a caution and his own separate s. 254(3) demand. [ 106 ] He said that he had set up the 8000C and put it through its self-diagnostic procedures and all of the results and calibration tests printed out by the instrument seemed to be within the proper parameters. [ 107 ] He said that he had taken a breath sample at 5:07 p.m. from Mr. Mudryk which registered a reading of 291 milligrams of alcohol per 100 millilitres of blood.
At 5:31 p.m. he took a second adequate sample which registered 275 milligrams of alcohol in 100 millilitres of blood. [ 108 ] The Crown then intended to take the officer through his Alcohol Influence Report which included questions and answers between him and the accused between the two breath tests. Mr. Ashurov indicated that a voir dire was required into the voluntariness of those utterances and, therefore, P.C. Caron was sworn in on a voluntariness voir dire . [ 109 ] P.C. Caron testified that before he took either of the two breath samples from Mr.
Mudryk he had spoken with the doctor who was attending him at the Joseph Brant hospital and he had been informed by the doctor that Mr. Mudryk could medically provide the breath samples. [ 110 ] Between the two breath tests P.C. Caron conducted what he described as his alcohol influence report, a document which is commonly prepared by qualified Intoxilyzer technicians between the taking of the two breath tests. He specifically testified that he had not threatened Mr.
Mudryk or offered him any inducement or promise of favour or suggested any negative result to him if he refused to answer any of the questions which the officer was then preparing to ask pursuant to alcohol influence report. [ 111 ] P.C. Caron described Mr. Mudryk as responsive although he did not know if he was on any medication at the hospital. He said that to the best of his knowledge no other officer had threatened or offered any inducements or promises of favour to Mr. Mudryk either and as a matter of fact Mr.
Ashurov was kind enough to inform the Court that that aspect of this voir dire was not really in issue. [ 112 ] P.C. Caron then testified about the actual questions he had asked and the answers he received on the alcohol influence report. He had asked Mr. Mudryk if he had been operating a motor vehicle and Mr. Mudryk said that he had been by answering ‘yes’. He asked him when he had been operating it and where he had started operating the vehicle. With respect to the latter question, Mr. Mudryk gave an answer to the effect that he had begun driving from Guelph Line.
When asked what the time was at that moment in the interaction between Mr. Mudryk and P.C. Caron the officer said that Mr. Mudryk said that it was 3:00 p.m. when it was actually 5:00 p.m. He asked him if he had been drinking and Mr. Mudryk answered “Yes, Laker – 1 beer at home began at 9:00 a.m. and finished 20 minutes later.” [ 113 ] In his final submissions later, Mr. Ashurov submitted that the Court should consider the answer by Mr.
Mudryk that was driving from Guelph Line to be non-sensical and illogical given the fact that his vehicle was described as driving westbound towards Guelph Line at the time when the collision occurred at the intersection of Dundas Highway and Sutton Drive. [ 114 ] P.C. Caron said that Mr. Mudryk did not complain of being ill and did not indicate that he was taking any medications at the time. [ 115 ] When he was asked if he was injured as a result of the accident he said that he had been and it was his right arm. He said that
he had not bumped his head. [ 116 ] At one point P.C. Caron said that he had asked Mr. Mudryk if he had been drinking alcoholic beverages since the accident and Mr. Mudryk denied that he had done so. [ 117 ] Describing his physical observations of Mr. Mudryk at the time, P.C. Caron said that he had detected the odour of an alcoholic beverage on his breath and that his eyes were blood shot and red rimmed with dilated pupils. He described him as being cooperative and indifferent in his attitude. He said that his speech was fair with an accent. He concluded that the effects of alcohol upon Mr.
Mudryk were obvious to him and that his ability to operate his motor vehicle was impaired by alcohol. [ 118 ] After the second test had been concluded, P.C. Caron said that he informed Mr. Mudryk of the results and told him quite frankly at that time that he did not believe Mr. Mudryk’s one beer story. At that point he said Mr. Mudryk then told him that he had consumed maybe five to six beers and lots of vodka the previous evening until approximately 1:00 or 2:00 a.m. [ 119 ] In cross examination he agreed with Mr.
Ashurov that he had only written the words “How many drinks?” in his notebook as a reference to the question he asked Mr. Mudryk after the second breath test when he told him that he didn’t really believe the story. He agreed that his opinion of the impairment of the accused was based on the information received in P.C. Urie’s RPG for arrest sheet and also on his own observations of the accused. [ 120 ] The Crown then closed its case on the voir dire with the evidence of P.C. Caron being concluded. [ 121 ] Mr. Ashurov called Mr. Mudryk as a witness on the
section 7/voluntariness voir dire . He said that he is 36 years of age and is now a Canadian citizen, although originally emigrating from the Ukraine. He is married and has two daughters, no criminal record and, at the present time, unemployed. [ 122 ] On August 11, 2011 he was working as a Bell Canada company contractor to install satellite TV dishes often involving installations on roof tops. [ 123 ] He said that after the collision he was in a state of shock and he did not even realize what had happened fully. He said he certainly was not thinking straight.
When he was at the hospital he had an IV of some unknown substance given to him by the medical personnel which made him feel good, kind of a light feeling, he said, not like the feeling he had when he first arrived at the hospital. [ 124 ] He said that he recalled speaking to P.C. Caron and he answered his questions because, according to law, one must respond to police questions. He explained that this was exactly the way it was when he was living in the Ukraine.
He also said that because he had had a collision with a truck, he realized that he had to answer any questions that the officer asked about the collision and this was all part of the procedure. He claimed not to have even realized that he had been arrested by P.C. Urie for any criminal offences until a later day when he had taken the time to read the paperwork given to him. [ 125 ] Mr. Ashurov asked him if he recalled being offered the opportunity to speak with a lawyer by the police and he said, “Yes, I think they did, but I wasn’t paying too much attention at that time”. [ 126 ] Mr.
Ashurov asked him why he had provided breath tests at the time and the accused said that they were simply part and parcel of the procedure that was required after a motor vehicle collision. Again, he pointed out that this was the same as in the Ukraine. [ 127 ] He confirmed his injuries by stating that he had a broken arm, a broken vertebrae, broken ribs and one of those broken ribs had punctured one of his lungs. He also had contusions on both knees. [ 128 ] At this point in Mr.
Mudryk’s evidence in Chief the Crown interrupted and asked if it would be possible to interrupt the actual voir dire to accommodate a witness from the Centre of Forensic Sciences (CFS), and Mr. Ashurov consented to that request. [ 129 ] The Crown then called Dr. Darryl Mayers who testified in Chief that he is a CFS toxicologist. Mr. Ashurov consented to have me qualify Dr.
Mayers as an expert witness capable of giving toxicological evidence with respect to the absorption, distribution and elimination of alcohol in the human body and also on the effects of alcohol on the human body and the ability to operate a motor vehicle. [ 130 ] Dr. Mayers said that he had listened in court to the evidence of P.C. Caron and he was of the opinion that P.C. Caron had operated the Intoxilyzer 8000C in a proper fashion. [ 131 ] Referring to his report, he said that his conclusion was that Mr.
Mudryk’s blood alcohol concentration at the time of the collision, which had been information that he had gleaned from Crown disclosure provided to him, would have been between 275 milligrams of alcohol in 100 millilitres of his blood and 325 milligrams of alcohol in 100 millilitres of his blood. [ 132 ] Dr. Mayers then said that such a BAC level would, of course, render a person’s ability to operate a motor vehicle impaired by that alcohol level. He said that reaction times and choices of driving maneuvres are impaired at that level of blood alcohol concentration.
In addition, there would definitely be a loss of peripheral vision acuity. [ 133 ] He said that in his opinion everyone’s ability to operate a motor vehicle is impaired by alcohol at a BAC level of 50. He was unaware of any other toxicologist having an opinion that it would take a reading of greater than 100 milligrams of alcohol in 100 millilitres of blood to have one’s ability to operate a motor vehicle impaired by alcohol. He said if there is any debate, it is about the levels between 50 and 100. [ 134 ] Mr. Ashurov did not take any serious issue with the evidence of Dr. Mayers.
The trial was then remanded to August 30, 2012 for the continuation of the evidence of Mr. Mudryk on the voir dire . Mr. Ashurov informed the Court that he had completed his examination in Chief and cross-examination then was conducted by Ms. Mackenzie.
[ 135 ] The accused said that he was able to recall the actual collision and the fact that people had approached his van to offer help to him, but not necessarily all of the details. He recalled “Bill” Pejakovic asking him if he was okay. He recalled answering that he was, but he said that he did not really understand the entire complexity of the situation at the time. The Crown asked him if he recalled Mr. Pejakovic giving him a water bottle and Mr.
Mudryk said that he did, but he pointed out that the photographic exhibit shows a different type of water bottle with a different name on it than the one which was given to him by Mr. Pejakovic. Therefore, he was telling the Court that he can remember that particular minute detail. [ 136 ] He said that he sort of recalled Mrs. Machry being present as well. [ 137 ] He did recall the police asking him if he was okay when they arrived. When asked whether he could recall ambulance personnel talking to him and the fire personnel, he said that he could in general remember them.
He said that as far as he recalled, they were trying to get him out of the van. The Crown asked him if would agree that he had been awake and conscious during all of this procedure and he disagreed by saying that it might be taking it too far to say that he was awake and alert. He said that he was in shock and scared and disoriented. [ 138 ] The Crown directed his mind to his interaction with the ambulance attendants and asked him if he recalled the police officer and an EMS person sitting in the ambulance with him. His answer was that that would be normal for EMS to be present.
However, he did not recall two other people being in the ambulance with him, although he said that they could have been for all he knew. He said that his field of vision was limited when he was in the ambulance. He said that he did not hear two voices talking when he was in the ambulance. [ 139 ] Specifically, he denied recalling being arrested in the ambulance and he did not recall telling anyone that he had had one beer at 9:00 a.m. when this was asked of him in the ambulance or perhaps at the hospital, if it was asked. [ 140 ] Ms.
Mackenzie then read in court the contents of the s. 254(3) Criminal Code demand for samples of breath to him and asked him if he recognized the wording. He said that he did not recall that demand being read to him at the scene or while in the ambulance. Neither did he recall a police caution being read to him. Neither did he recall a demand for samples of breath being read to him at the hospital.
He said that he did recall a police officer standing nearby him in the hospital, but he did not recall if the officer was with him at all times. [ 141 ] He had no recollection, he said, of the police asking him if he wanted to speak to a lawyer at the hospital. [ 142 ] He said that he did recall a second officer at the hospital other than P.C.
Urie, who had a device with him into which he was asked to breathe. [ 143 ] He said he was not really sure that the police were investigating him as opposed to just collecting information as part of the procedure after a motor vehicle collision. [ 144 ] He did agree that he was not surprised that the police asked him for breath samples because it was the same as in the Ukraine when you have an accident with a motor vehicle.
He said he first realized that he was charged with these offences the next day when he was showing his wife his paperwork that he had been given after being arrested and released later from the hospital. He said that even when he signed his papers at the hospital he only put a “squiggly” on the paper because he could not really sign properly. I assume that he meant because of his injury to his elbow. [ 145 ] The Crown asked him what his comment was with respect to the witnesses who have testified and said that his responses to them were responsive and appropriate.
He said that he could not comment except to say that the questions asked by the civilians were very, very simple in content. [ 146 ] He agreed that both officers who had questioned him had asked him if he understood and he said that he did tell them he understood because he understood generally but not all of the details.
He even expanded that answer by saying that even though in court he was being helped by a court accredited interpreter, he still could not understand all of the things that were being talked about in court. [ 147 ] He said he had no idea what, if anything, was in the IV unit that he had in his arm at the hospital. [ 148 ] The Crown then directed his attention to some of the questions and answers that P.C. Caron had discussed from the Alcohol Influence Report. The accused said that he answered those questions because that is the law when police ask questions.
The Crown asked him if he agreed that he was under the influence of alcohol at the scene of the collision and in the ambulance and also at the hospital. Mr. Mudryk said that he was not under the influence of alcohol in the van right after the accident, but he was under the influence in the ambulance and also at the hospital and also perhaps affected by some medications that had been given to him at the hospital. [ 149 ] He then stated that he had had “a drink” after the collision and he said that that might have been affecting him at the time when he was discussing matters with P.C.
Caron on the Alcohol Influence Report. The Crown then asked him to quantify what he meant by “a drink” after the collision. Mr. Mudryk said that he had consumed a full 375 millilitre bottle of vodka, plus one-third of another 375 millilitre bottle, which would therefore mean that he had consumed 500 millilitres approximately of vodka. Both counsel agreed that that would equal approximately 17 or 18 ounces of vodka.
He explained that he had purchased two 375-millilitre vodka bottles just before he was involved in the collision with the dump truck. [ 150 ] He then also explained that these bottles had screw tops on them which allowed him to unscrew them in order to consume their contents. He said that he had gulped a few mouthfuls of the second bottle and that is why he was estimating that he had consumed approximately one-third of it after he had guzzled the entire 375 millilitre contents of the first bottle. [ 151 ] In re-examination by Mr.
Ashurov, he was asked what he had meant by stating that his field of vision had been compromised in the ambulance. Mr. Mudryk said that he was facing the back door of the ambulance but he had a cervical collar on his neck and that is
what he meant by the restriction of peripheral vision. [ 152 ] Mr. Ashurov asked him for an explanation for his answer to P.C. Caron that he had been driving from Guelph Line when his vehicle had obviously been driving in a westerly direction towards Guelph Line before the accident. Mr. Mudryk explained that he lived in Oakville and he was really driving from home in Oakville and that, therefore, he really was not going east from Guelph Line because he was driving in a westerly direction. [ 153 ] At the conclusion of the re-examination by Mr. Ashurov, I asked some questions for clarification of Mr. Mudryk.
First of all, Mr. Mudryk confirmed that he was telling the Court that he had consumed one full 375-millilitre bottle of vodka and, in addition, approximately a third of a second 375-millilitre bottle of vodka after the collision and before the first emergency personnel responded.
I asked him why he only consumed a third of the second bottle and his answer was that because all of the emergency people had arrived, the police, the ambulance, and he did not really remember who arrived first, but he said they came right up to him and began to try to help him to try to drag him out of the vehicle. [ 154 ] He told the Court that he had purchased the vodka bottles before arriving at that intersection and he had placed them on the passenger seat right next to him. After the collision when he opened his eyes, he said they just happened to be “right there at my feet”.
I clarified with him that what he was saying was that after the dump truck had smashed right through the passenger door and passenger side of his van, the bottles, as he said, got shifted right towards him. He further explained that the bottles had been shifted to a point where they landed right next to his right thigh within his reach. Mr. Mudryk demonstrated in court by placing his hand on an area of his right leg between his knee and his hip, and both counsel agreed that he appeared to be describing the thigh area of his right leg. [ 155 ] I then asked Mr.
Mudryk how he had been able to access those bottles given that the airbag had been deployed and he explained that both airbags had “shot out, they deployed, but this, this airbag was higher. I, I mean it was somewhere up here that it didn’t, you know, prevent me from reaching what was here”. [ 156 ] I then was able to clarify with Mr. Mudryk that he was trying to illustrate that the driver’s side airbag, after it deployed, was about chest high where it settled on his body and, therefore, still allowed him to be able to reach down to his right thigh area to grasp the vodka bottles.
When I asked him to explain how he was able to get the deployed airbag out of the way of his face so that he could consume the vodka, he said that he thought he kind of turned or leaned sideways and turned a little bit so that he could take a drink “away from me”. [ 157 ] I then thanked Mr. Mudryk for answering these questions for my own clarification and asked both counsel if they had any questions arising out of my questions. Ms. Mackenzie had none, but Mr. Ashurov did. [ 158 ] Mr. Ashurov asked the accused how long the airbag had remained inflated. Mr.
Mudryk said that it was hard to say and said that it sort of sagged in front of him, it was limp in front of him, and together with the broken steering wheel, it was “right there staring at my face”. [ 159 ] Mr. Ashurov then asked Mr. Mudryk if the airbag had still been in his face when he began to drink the vodka and Mr. Mudryk responded, “No, it was not. No, it wasn’t right at my face. It was in front of me some a little bit of a distance here, it was kind of sagging. I was able to move it. Maybe it was, I don’t know, partially inflated, but anyways I, I could just move it”.
At that point he said that the airbag was perhaps close to a metre away from his face even before it sagged and he also said that it might have been partially deflated. [ 160 ] At this point counsel and the Court engaged in a scheduling discussion after Mr. Mudryk was returned to his seat in the courtroom, but after that discussion I realized I had not covered an area of questioning for clarification, so I asked Mr. Mudryk to take the witness stand again. At that point I covered the evidence that he had given that he had suffered a broken arm arising out of the collision.
He confirmed that it was his right arm and it was his forearm area that was broken. I asked him if he had realized that his arm was broken at the time when he was drinking from the vodka bottles. He said that he had felt the pain and also there was blood, but he had not realized that it was actually broken at that point. [ 161 ] I then asked him if he could confirm that he was able to use the hand of his broken arm to handle the vodka bottles. He said, “Well, I, I was fine holding it, the bottle, but I of course, of course used the other hand to, to open the bottle”. Mr.
Mudryk confirmed that by the other hand he had meant his left hand. [ 162 ] Again, I asked counsel if either one of them had any questions arising out of the Court’s supplementary questions for clarification and neither counsel did. [ 163 ] Mr. Ashurov then closed the case for the defence on the voluntariness voir dire and the Crown did not call any reply evidence on that voir dire . After scheduling discussions, both counsel agreed to make their submissions to the Court on the voluntariness voir dire on December 12, 2012.
The trial was accordingly remanded to that date. [ 164 ] On December 12, 2012, at the outset of proceedings, both counsel asked the Court to entertain the submissions on the voluntariness voir dire after the Crown completed calling three additional witnesses. Mr. Ashurov informed the Court that he would also be arguing his s. 7 Charter application contemporaneously with the voluntariness argument on the voir dire . [ 165 ] The Crown then called Captain Chris Choluka who testified in Chief that he is a member of the Burlington Fire Department. On August 11, 2011 he was dispatched to the scene of the collision.
He arrived with his crew at 2:53 p.m. When he arrived he found one paramedic already present. He noted that the dump truck had pushed the passenger seat of the accused’s van forward and sideways around the accused driver’s right arm and was, thus, pinning him into his driver’s compartment. [ 166 ] He found empty alcoholic beverage bottles and cans in the rear of the van and, in his opinion, they were inaccessible to the driver in his pinned in position in the driver’s compartment.
He also said that he found no bottles or cans of an alcoholic beverage description in the driver’s compartment area and he did not see the accused drinking from any kind of a bottle, including a water bottle.
[ 167 ] Captain Choluka said it took 45 minutes to extricate Mudryk from the vehicle. He said that he personally was never closer than two or three feet away from Mudryk’s face and body. He also gave the opinion that Mr. Mudryk could not have been drinking any alcoholic beverages or, for that matter, any beverage at all while the process of extrication was taking place. [ 168 ] In cross-examination he denied having been asked specifically by the police about Mr. Mudryk’s opportunity to access bottles or cans of alcoholic beverages while in the vehicle.
He did agree that it was possible that some items may have remained in the van after the ones that he had observed being removed were removed. [ 169 ] He said that he never had observed more than one ambulance at the scene when he arrived, but he did eventually notice that there were two paramedics present. [ 170 ] In re-examination he said that the dispatch times are a matter of record on his fire department occurrence report. He therefore was able to get those times for his notes from that report. Mr. Ashurov then expressed a desire to have disclosure of that occurrence report and Ms.
Mackenzie undertook to have Captain Choluka obtain it for him. [ 171 ] I asked a question of Captain Choluka and he told me that he had not seen the airbag in the sense that he had not taken any note of the status of the airbag. [ 172 ] The next witness called by the Crown was Timothy Nykamp who testified in Chief that he works with the Halton Advanced Care Paramedic Department. He was dispatched at 14:48, in other words 2:48 p.m., and arrived at 2:54 p.m. at the collision scene.
Fire department personnel and one ambulance were already there when he arrived and his own supervisor arrived shortly after him. [ 173 ] He said that he had spoken to the accused and found that his answers were vague and he had to repeat his questions to the accused.
He also noticed the odour of alcohol on the accused’s breath. [ 174 ] He had not noticed any alcoholic beverage cans or bottles in the driver’s area of the vehicle, but on the other hand he said he was not really looking for any at that time. [ 175 ] In cross-examination he said that on the day in question he had prepared a patient care report that was submitted to the hospital to which he took the accused. In February 2012 he said the police had requested a statement from him. Therefore, he had to ask the EMS management personnel to obtain that report that he had authored for him.
I should have mentioned that before he began his testimony in-Chief, that EMS report had been qualified and he was permitted to refresh his memory from it. [ 176 ] He said that he did not recall, but it was possible that the police had told him that his February statement was needed because of their impaired driving investigation with respect to Mr. Mudryk. [ 177 ] He said that he had been as close as a foot away from Mr.
Mudryk’s face while he was in his presence treating him and he had no trouble detecting the odour of an alcohol beverage on his breath as opposed to an odour of antifreeze. [ 178 ] With respect to his EMS report which he actually produced at that point in his testimony because he did have it with him, he said that there was no reference in it to the vagueness of Mr. Mudryk’s answers or that Mr. Mudryk had seemed to be too casual for the circumstances as he had testified in Chief. This witness had also said that Mr. Mudryk was too casual, as well as giving vague answers.
He agreed that such comments were not in his ambulance call report either. [ 179 ] He also said that he had inserted an IV saline solution bag connection into Mr. Mudryk’s left elbow at the front of it and that that IV remained in that location until they reached the hospital. [ 180 ] There was no re-examination by the Crown. [ 181 ] The next witness called by the Crown was Detective Constable Kevin Rye who testified in Chief that he is an officer with the HRPS and he currently works in motor vehicle accident and collision reconstruction.
Previously he had police experience in Merseyside and Liverpool in the United Kingdom from 1988 to 2004. He said that he had arrived at the collision scene at 3:41 p.m. and took photographs of that scene. On consent, 15 photographs were introduced through him as Exhibit Number 10A through 10O. [ 182 ] He said that he had not prepared an actual reconstruction report in this case.
He also said that he had not seen any bottles or cans in the driver’s compartment that would appear to be alcohol beverage containers when he was taking his photographs. [ 183 ] In cross-examination he said that he, of course, was not looking for alcohol beverage containers and, therefore, it was possible that there could have been one or more in the driver’s compartment or the body of the van and he may not have noticed them. [ 184 ] He said that the speed limit on Dundas Highway at the Sutton intersection at that time was 60 kilometres per hour. [ 185 ] With respect to Mr.
Mudryk’s injuries, he said that when he spoke to a nurse at the Hamilton General Hospital the next day he was told that Mr. Mudryk had cracked ribs. [ 186 ] In re-examination by the Crown he said that he was quite familiar with that stretch of road because he drives it often and he was certain of the 60 kilometre per hour limit in August 2011. [ 187 ] At the conclusion of this witness, Ms. Mackenzie closed the Crown’s case in response to the s. 8, 9, 10 and 10(
b) Charter application by Mr. Mudryk. She also closed the case for the Crown on the voluntariness/s. 7 Charter voir dire with respect to the utterances of Mr. Mudryk to P.C. Caron in the breath room. The Crown also closed its case on the merits of each of the two counts pursuant to s. 253(1) (
a) and 253(1) (
b) on this blended Charter and trial proceeding. [ 188 ] The Court then received submissions from both the Crown and defence on the s. 7 Charter and voluntariness components of the voir dire into the utterances made by Mr. Mudryk to P.C. Caron in the breath room. I reserved my ruling to December 18, 2012, and
on that day I gave an oral conclusory ruling with reasons to follow. I found that I was satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt by the Crown that the statements made by Mr. Mudryk were voluntary and that he had not established on a balance of probabilities, as is his onus, that the questions contained in that interview constituted a breach of his s. 7 Charter rights. [ 189 ] At the conclusion of my brief oral ruling, Mr. Ashurov elected to call a defence on the merits of the case.
He also agreed as requested by the Crown to have the Court apply all of the evidence on the voluntariness/s. 7 voir dire to the body of trial evidence and I did so. [ 190 ] The first witness called by the defence was Roy Bhimsingh who testified in Chief that on August 11, 2011 he was the dump truck driver involved in the collision with the accused’s van. He testified in Chief that he was travelling at about 50 kilometres per hour when he reached the intersection. He said that the van had turned left in front of him and, therefore, he collided with it. [ 191 ] Mr.
Ashurov presented his Highway Traffic Act record to him and he admitted it and it was entered as Exhibit 11A on this trial. It contains eight previous speeding convictions. In addition, he admitted to entering a plea of guilty to a charge of operating a commercial motor vehicle with a major defect on January 3, 2012 in Milton Provincial Offences Court.
He agreed that this charge arose out of the collision on August 11, 2011 when he struck the van. [ 192 ] He said that, in his opinion, he would need 50 to 100 feet to stop his empty dump truck at 30 kilometres per hour and about 125 feet at 50 kilometres per hour. [ 193 ] He admitted that his inside tire on one of his rear axles had begun to lose air after he left the dump on Appleby Line. He was shown his police statement in order to refresh his memory and he agreed that he had told the officer that that tire had “a little bit of air” left in it. [ 194 ] Mr.
Bhimsingh said that he had been injured himself in the collision and he was in the process of suing Mr. Mudryk. On consent, a statutory declaration that had been signed by him on June 12, 2012 was introduced as Exhibit Number 12. [ 195 ] Mr. Ashurov also entered his updated Highway Traffic Act record as Exhibit Number 11B. [ 196 ] In cross-examination by the Crown he was referred to paragraph five of his Exhibit Number 12 statutory declaration. He explained that he believed that in that paragraph he had listed his injuries and other consequences that had affected him as a result of this collision.
He acknowledged that his truck’s air braking system had been defective at the time, but he maintained that that did not affect his ability to stop the dump truck because the truck has five braking systems in total. [ 197 ] He also stated he is a licenced truck mechanic and he does his own repairs. [ 198 ] He also commented that the fact that he had low air pressure in one of the inside rear tires on his rear axle was no big impediment to the operation of the truck. [ 199 ] He estimated that he was about 20 feet from the intersection when he noticed the van begin to turn left in front of him.
However, he then revised that answer to say that actually he was even into the intersection when he first saw the van begin its turn. [ 200 ] He categorically disagreed that the speed of his truck was between 60 and 80 kilometres per hour at the time of reaching the intersection. [ 201 ] The next witness called by Mr. Ashurov was the accused Maryan Mudryk and it was again confirmed just before the questioning began in Chief that his evidence on the voluntariness/s.7 voir dire would be applied to the trial. Mr.
Mudryk testified with the assistance of a Russian Interpreter. [ 202 ] He testified in Chief that on August 11, 2011 he had arisen in the morning at 7:00 a.m., had breakfast and checked out his work schedule, noticing that his first client for whom he had to work for Bell Canada that day was scheduled for between 2:00 and 3:00 p.m. at a residence near Sutton Drive. He also had other appointments scheduled for later in the day.
Therefore, he said that he did not leave home until 2:00 p.m. [ 203 ] When he did so, he said that he drove directly to the LCBO store to buy some alcoholic beverages for consumption at home during the evening after he completed his scheduled work duties. He said it was very usual for him to drink at home at the end of a hard day of work. [ 204 ] He said that at this time he was still unemployed and he has been taking rehabilitation treatment for alcoholism at Wayside House in Hamilton.
The program was a residential program and it was completed on December 28, 2012 having commenced the program on October 29, 2012. Mr. Ashurov introduced at that time as Exhibit Number 13, on consent, a copy of the Wayside House report dated November 6, 2012. He said that before taking this program he used to drink every single day for about a year. [ 205 ] Mr. Ashurov directed his mind to the events of August 11, 2011. Mr.
Mudryk said that he had consumed one bottle of beer between 9:00 and 10:00 a.m. in the morning at home and when he left his home and went to the LCBO store he had purchased two mickeys of vodka and the brand was Banff Ice. He denied consuming any alcoholic beverage ever before he went to work and he never drove drunk, he said. [ 206 ] He was asked to comment on the different brands of vodka and other beer cans that were found in the back of his Bell Canada van after the collision. He said that he often drank from the bottle while sitting in his van after work.
I assume that he meant once he had driven the van home that he sometimes sat and drank in his van. Therefore, he said, that is why the containers would be in the van at that time. He said that it was quite common for him after work to consume an entire mickey of vodka and several beers as chasers. It should be mentioned at this time that it is generally agreed that a mickey is a 12-ounce bottle or a 330-millilitre bottle of vodka.
[ 207 ] He was asked to comment upon events after the accident on August 11, 2011. He said that he had consumed a full mickey and one-third of a second bottle of the same size immediately after the impact. He was asked his body weight and he said it was 65 kilograms. He was asked why he would have consumed that alcohol at that time after the accident. He said that it seemed like a good way to relieve the stress that had been brought to bear upon him caused by having this terrible collision. [ 208 ] At one point Mr. Ashurov asked the accused: Q. Why did you down this amount of alcohol after the accident, sir? Mr.
Mudryk replied: Well, to me I guess it was the most acceptable or accessible way to cope with stress, to lose stress and pain, and pain, and that’s something that helped me before. Q. Do you recall what you did with the bottles after you drank from them? A. I just basically tossed them away. Q. Do you recall where? A. As far as I – as far as I can remember, I kind of tossed them over my shoulder behind me. [ 209 ] Mr. Ashurov asked him to comment on the interview with P.C. Caron between the two breath tests that P.C. Caron had testified about in his Alcohol Influence Report. Mr.
Mudryk said that he no longer had any recollection of telling P.C. Caron that he had been driving from the Guelph Line. He also had no recollection of telling Caron that he had not been drinking after the collision. [ 210 ] He was then asked to explain why he had decided to attend Wayside House for rehabilitation.
He said that he began to drink to an even greater degree after this collision and the charges that were facing him, so he therefore decided finally that he needed professional help. [ 211 ] He confirmed that his driver’s licence is under suspension by the Ministry of Transportation of Ontario (MTO) because he had begun to have involuntary convulsions sometimes after heavy drinking bouts and that is the reason that they suspended him. [ 212 ] He explained that after he was treated at the hospital for his injuries arising out of this collision he had some seizures after taking some of the pain medications to which he, after the fact, realized he was apparently allergic. [ 213 ] He also stated that he had been taken by ambulance to the hospital on occasion after he suffered convulsions from drinking even without ingesting the painkillers.
He explained that the painkillers had been cancelled by his medical personnel at the hospital once he began to have seizures, and these ambulance calls, of course, had to be reported to the Ministry. [ 214 ] Finally, he was asked if he ever weighed as much as 80 kilograms and he denied ever having weighed that much.
First of all, he clarified that his height was a little over six feet in English terms. [ 215 ] In cross-examination by the Crown He said that he had been picked up by ambulance from his home approximately eight times for seizures between August 11, 2011 and the summer of 2012, but never before the August 11 collision. [ 216 ] With respect to the Alcohol Influence Report interview with P.C. Caron, he said that he recalled some of the questions and answers that he had engaged in with P.C.
Caron, but not the particulars of them. [ 217 ] He recalled providing his breath samples but not exactly when, and by that he seemed to clarify that he meant whether he gave them together or whether they were separated in time by some number of minutes. Specifically, he said that he had no recollection of the question from the officer about whether or not he had been drinking that night.
He agreed with the Crown that the officer appeared to be writing his answers just as he had testified that he did. [ 218 ] The following exchange took place in cross-examination of the accused: Question by the Crown: And so, sir, with respect to – do you recall then what you said to him when he asked you if you had been drinking since the accident? A. No, I don’t remember. Q. You don’t remember. So if his notes say that when you said – when he asked you if you’d been drinking since the accident, his notes indicate that you answered no, you can’t comment on that? A.
I can only suppose that that’s how I might have answered that question, but I don’t remember the question itself and I’m not sure exactly how I answered it. THE COURT: Let me just catch that answer again. Can you just repeat that for me so I can let that percolate? A. I suppose that based on these notes that he could – he could’ve asked me that kind of question and that’s how I could’ve answered, but I don’t remember that question per se and response – my response to it. THE COURT: Okay. So, I think to understand the answer which is that – let me make see [sic] if I get this straight, sir.
You’re saying to me today that given that the officer made notes of these questions and answers, you’re at least prepared to say it’s possible that he asked that question about whether you had been drinking after the accident, correct? And it’s possible that you may have answered to him, no, if he wrote it down, but you don’t remember either that question or that answer, is that what I understand, correct?
A. Yes, sir. THE COURT: All right, thank you. [ 219 ] Mr.
Mudryk also clarified that he was providing these answers to the Court because he realized that the officer had made notes to the effect of all these questions and answers. [ 220 ] He said that he had heard in court from the officer that he had told the officer that he had been driving westbound on Dundas towards Sutton and that he had started driving at Guelph Line, but he could not really comment on the illogicality of those converse concepts because he did not really recall the question and answer. [ 221 ] He agreed that he did recall being asked questions by Caron and that he had answered them and that this was all happening while the officer was preparing some kind of test.
But the accused only presumed that the officer had asked those questions and that he, the accused, had given those answers. [ 222 ] Specifically, he said that he had no recollection of telling the officer that he had not consumed alcohol after the collision or that he was not ill or taking medications.
The accused had specifically stated, “I don’t remember the question, but I suppose that had this question been asked, that’s how I would’ve responded because it – it’s true that I was not ill and was not taking my medication”. [ 223 ] He said that having a beer at 9:00 a.m. at breakfast time was unusual for him because he usually begins his work in the morning. However, on August 11, 2011 he said that he only began his calls at 2:00 p.m. or so. He denied the Crown’s suggestion that he had had this beer in the morning because he had no control over his desire for alcohol. He ma
[…]
Loading document…