R. v. Woods, 2013 ONCJ 72
Opinion
COURT FILE NO.: St. Catharines - 2111-998-11-N4116-00 2111-998-12-N0620-00 DATE: 2013·02·14 Citation: R. v. Woods , 2013 ONCJ 72 ONTARIO COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN — AND — DANIEL WOODS Before Justice D.A. Harris Heard on July 11, 2012 and October 22, 2012 Reasons for Sentence delivered on February 14, 2013 D. Anger ................................................................................................. for the Federal Crown M.
DelGobbo ............................................................................ for the accused, Daniel Woods REASONS FOR SENTENCE HARRIS J.: [ 1 ] Daniel Woods entered guilty pleas to two counts of possession of cocaine for the purpose of trafficking. [ 2 ] He is before me today to be sentenced. [ 3 ] Crown counsel argued that the total sentence should be one of imprisonment for between four and five years. He also requested a firearms prohibition, a DNA order and a forfeiture order. [ 4 ] Counsel for Mr.
Woods argued that the total sentence should be imprisonment for between 18 months and two years less one day, followed by probation. He did not oppose the ancillary orders sought by Crown counsel. [ 5 ] My task then, is to determine the appropriate sentence for Mr. Woods. [ 6 ] In doing this, I must consider the facts underlying the offences here. I must consider Mr. Woods’ background. Finally, I must consider the fundamental purpose and principle of sentencing as set out in the Criminal Code . I propose to address each of these in that order.
THE FACTS [ 7 ] On September 28, 2011, Niagara Regional Police officers were watching Mr. Woods when he met a known cocaine dealer/user and engaged in a drug transaction. The police officers moved in and arrested Mr. Woods. [ 8 ] He was in possession of two bags containing a total of 36.5 grams of cocaine, which was worth $3,500. He also had $1,130 in cash in his possession. He admitted that he had another two ounces of cocaine in his residence. The subsequent search of that residence turned up two bags of cocaine. Each weighed 29.5 grams. The total value for this was $5,000.
The police also found 16 ecstasy pills. [ 9 ] Mr. Woods was released on a Promise to Appear after he entered into an Undertaking before an Officer-In-Charge. [ 10 ] He was still bound by that Undertaking on February 16, 2012 when the police executed a search warrant at his residence and found 288.5 grams of cocaine, worth $25,000, plus 79 ecstasy pills, and $540 in cash.
BACKGROUND OF DANIEL WOODS [11] I have had the benefit of a Pre-Sentence Report which sets out much of Mr. Woods’ background. [12] He is now 24 years of age. He was 23 at the time that he committed these offences. [13] He did not have a criminal record. [14] He describes his childhood as “normal and uneventful”. His parents were good role models for him and his brother. Theyprovided him with “every opportunity to achieve success”.
He completed high school and one year at Brock University. [15] No mention was made of any legitimate employment history. [16] I was told that he had been selling drugs in order to support his gambling addiction. [17] Since being charged, Mr. Woods has been attending regular counselling to address his gambling addiction. [18] The Pre-Sentence Report notes that: The subject describes himself as outgoing, determined, andhardworking. He also stated that he is aware that at times he canbe “a challenge to get along with”, due to his impulsivebehaviour, and “too smart for his own good”.
The subjectexpressed remorse of his offence. He stated that he isdisappointed in himself, and feels ashamed that his actions havenegatively affected his family. The subject mentioned that heplans to return to school in the future. He would like to have acareer and become a productive member of society. He alsomentioned that he hopes over time to restore his family’s faith andtrust in him. [19] Counsel for Mr. Woods also filed a letter confirming Mr. Woods’ participation in counselling. THE LAW [20] The fundamental purpose of sentencing as expressed in
section 718 of the Criminal Code is to contribute to respect forthe law and the maintenance of a just, peaceful and safe society by imposing just sanctions that have one or more of the objectives ofdenunciation, deterring the offender and other persons from committing offences, separating offenders from society where necessary,assisting in rehabilitating offenders, providing reparation for harm done to victims or to the community, and promoting a sense ofresponsibility in offenders and acknowledgment of the harm done to victims and to the community. [21] The fundamental principle of sentencing is that the punishment should be proportionate to the gravity of the offence andthe degree of responsibility of the offender. [22] The punishment should fit the crime, but there is no single fit sentence for any particular offence.
The determination of anappropriate sentence involves attempting to apply a blend of the above principles, including specific and general deterrence,denunciation and rehabilitation. [23]
Section 718.2(
e) of the Criminal Code provides that All available sanctions, other than imprisonment, that arereasonable in the circumstances should be considered for alloffenders, … [24] Appellate courts in Ontario have long recognized the fact that this principle is even more applicable in cases involvingyouthful first offenders. [25] For example, in R. v. Priest, (ON CA), [1996] O.J. No. 3369 (Ont. C.A.), Rosenberg J.A. wrote atpara. 17 that The primary objectives in sentencing a first offender areindividual deterrence and rehabilitation.
Except for very seriousoffences and offences involving violence, this court has held thatthese objectives are not only paramount but best achieved byeither a suspended sentence and probation or a very short term ofimprisonment followed by a term of probation. [26] He went on to say at para. 18 that “the sentence should constitute the minimum necessary intervention that is adequate inthe particular circumstances”. [27] Then at para. 20:
The duty to explore other dispositions for a first offender beforeimposing a custodial sentence is not an empty formalism whichcan be avoided merely by invoking the objective of generaldeterrence. It should be clear from the record of the proceedings,preferably in the trial judge’s reasons, why the circumstances ofthis particular case require that this first offender must receive asentence of imprisonment. [28] These principles are not to be considered in a vacuum however. [29] In that regard I note the statements of the Ontario Court of Appeal in two decisions referred to by counsel. [30] In R. v.
Bajada, (ON CA), [2003] O.J. No. 721 (Ont. C.A.), Weiler J.A. stated at paras. 12 and 13that 12 In his book, Sentencing, 5th ed. (Toronto: Butterworths,1999), Clayton C. Ruby states under the heading Cocaine at p.865-866: Cocaine used to be regarded by the courts as a drugwhich is somewhat more serious than marijuana butless serious than heroin. However, due to theexistence of crack cocaine and intravenous cocaineusers, this attitude seems to be changing.
Morerecent sentences for cocaine seem on par with thoseimposed for heroin possession or trafficking. .... in the case of Finlay and Grelette, the accusedwere convicted of what was described as a veryserious offence involving 20 ounces of high puritycocaine and were concluded to be close to the levelof importers. Sentences of four and one-half and sixand one-half years were imposed according to theaccuseds’ relative degrees of involvement.
The courtnoted that although general deterrence was theprimary factor to be considered in the imposition ofsentence, “the rehabilitation of the offender cannever be entirely overlooked and in each case theoffender must be dealt with as constructively as thecircumstances of the case permit”.
13 It would appear that sentences of five to five and one halfyears are not uncommon for possession of a substantial amount ofcocaine for the purposes of trafficking following an accused’splea of guilty or where the accused has no prior record. See e.g.R. v. Marton, [1980] O.J. No. 868 (C.A.); R. v. Molino (1987), 2W.C.B. (2d) 391 (Ont. Dist. Ct.); R. v. Charles, [1997] O.J. No.2247 (Gen. Div.); R. v. Cummings, [1990] O.J. No. 2747 (Dist.Ct.); R. v. Jones (1999), (ON CA), 133 C.C.C.(3d) 1 (Ont. C.A.). In R. v. Finlay and Grelette, [1985] O.J.
No.236 (C.A.), referred to above, this court imposed a sentence of sixand a half years on an offender with one minor criminal offencefifteen years earlier, having regard to his position in the drughierarchy which was close to the level of an importer. Longersentences were upheld in R. v. Boughner, [1999] O.J. No. 5449(Sup. Ct.), aff’d (ON CA), [2002] O.J.
No.2181 (C.A.) where, in addition to credit of 14 months for 5months of pre-trial custody, the appellant was sentenced to fiveand a half years imprisonment for possession of 66 grams of 74%pure cocaine for the purpose of trafficking and possession ofmoney derived from the commission of an offence. Anaggravating factor was evidence that the appellant had beentrafficking in cocaine over the preceding one and a half years. Healso had three prior convictions for possession of a narcotic andone conviction for possession for the purpose of trafficking. InR. v.
Gibson (1996), (ON CA), 87 O.A.C. 393(C.A.), a sentence of eight years was upheld for trafficking incocaine with respect to a repeat narcotics offender with a seriouscriminal record apart from drug convictions. More recently, in R.v. Bertucci, (ON CA), [2002] O.J. No. 3870(C.A.), a sentence of seven years was considered by this court onan appeal from sentence respecting one count of conspiracy totraffic in cocaine following the appellant’s trial and conviction.Concurrent sentences respecting six counts of trafficking incocaine during an overlapping period were also imposed.
Thecourt stated that a sentence of seven years was a fit sentence forthe offence of conspiracy to traffic standing alone. However,having regard to the fact that one count of trafficking was setaside the court reduced the sentence to six years. [31] In an endorsement in R. v. Bryan, 2011 ONCA 273 , [2011] O.J. No. 1581 (Ont. C.A.), the Court stated at para.1 that Normally, in cases of this nature, sentences of 5 to 8 years wouldreflect the proper range for someone, without a record, convictedof possession for the purpose of trafficking in slightly more than apound of cocaine. ANALYSIS [32] Mr.
Woods was convicted of possession for the purpose of trafficking in just under 13.5 ounces or slightly less than apound of cocaine. [33] He was first caught with 95.5 grams of cocaine in September 2011. [34] While awaiting resolution of that charge, he was caught with another 288.5 grams of cocaine in February 2012. [35] As was indicated in the decisions of the Ontario Court of Appeal quoted above, cocaine is a very dangerous drug. [36] It is clearly a very serious offence for someone to be in possession of 96 grams of such a drug.
It is an offence that callsout for a sentence that makes it clear to anyone who might contemplate committing the same offence that we as a society will not toleratesuch behaviour. The sentence must make it clear that anyone who commits such an offence should expect to go to jail for a very longtime. [37] Keeping in mind that “the rehabilitation of the offender can never be entirely overlooked and in each case the offendermust be dealt with as constructively as the circumstances of the case permit” I could see my way clear to impose a reformatory rangesentence such as that proposed by counsel for Mr.
Woods had that been the full extent of the criminal acts committed by Mr. Woods. [38] After all, he is a young man who had never been convicted of anything prior to this. He is remorseful. He acceptsresponsibility for what he has done. He understands that it was wrong. He understands that he has to change if he is to stay away fromfuture criminality. He has undertaken the preliminary steps towards that change. [39] I have taken all of the above into account along with the fact that he entered guilty pleas.
[ 40 ] Finally, I have taken into account the comments in R. v. Woolcock , [2002] O.J. No. 4927 (Ont.
C.A.) where the Court stated at para. 13 that One of the dangers of imposing a lengthy term of imprisonment on facts such as these is that it could impair the rehabilitation and reintegration of this person as a responsible member of his community. [ 41 ] The Court then went on to state: It ought not to be overlooked that it is important that persons in prisons who are to be released at some time will not return to a life of crime but will become self-supporting, capable of assuming new responsibilities and turn in the direction of becoming useful members of society.
If a prison term is of such a length as to endanger the future rehabilitation of an accused, then the term of imprisonment imposed on him will not protect society in the future. [ 42 ] All this however is greatly reduced in significance as a result of the fact that while awaiting disposition of that first charge, Mr. Woods was found to be in possession of an even larger quantity of cocaine for the purpose of trafficking.
Under circumstances where I would expect him to be on his best behaviour, he committed an even more serious offence. [ 43 ] When I take that into account, along with all of the above-mentioned mitigating factors, the appropriate total sentence is well outside of the reformatory range. SENTENCE [ 44 ] With respect to the possession of cocaine for the purpose of trafficking committed on September 28, 2011, I sentence Mr. Woods to imprisonment for 18 months. [ 45 ] With respect to the possession of cocaine for the purpose of trafficking committed on February 16, 2012, I sentence Mr.
Woods to imprisonment for 30 months to be served consecutively. [ 46 ] I also make the following ancillary orders. [ 47 ] These are secondary designated offences. I make an order pursuant to
section 487.051 of the Criminal Code authorizing the taking from Mr. Woods of any number of samples of one or more bodily substances that are reasonably required for the purpose of forensic DNA analysis. [ 48 ] Pursuant to
section 109 of the Criminal Code , I prohibit Mr. Woods from owning, possessing or carrying any firearm, crossbow, prohibited weapon, restricted weapon, prohibited device, ammunition, prohibited ammunition or explosive substance for ten years. [ 49 ] I also make an order for the forfeiture of the money and the drug paraphernalia seized here. [ 50 ] Finally, I note that Mr. Woods will be without any financial income for a considerable period of time while he is in jail. He will not be in a position to pay anything. In light of that, I waive the victim fine surcharges. Released: February 14, 2013 Signed: “Justice D.A. Harris” _______________________ Justice D.A. Harris
Loading document…