The court, after hearing arguments on both sides, was of opinion, that the case was very properly submitted, under all the circumstances of the case, by the presiding judge to the jury, who had found a verdict for the plaintiffs; and as the loss of the original hill was a matter for their consideration, arising from the nature of the evidence offered, and the whole of the case together, the court did not think proper to disturb the verdict. Rule for new trial discharged. All the Judges present.