WEINSTEIN v. UNITED STATES; CHESTER v. SAME, 293 F. 388

PER CURIAM. The matter in controversy in these actions arises out of an indictment charging the' defendants with selling “a certain contrivance, or machine, designed and intended for use in the unlawful manufacture of intoxicating liquor, to wit, one three-gallon still complete.” The indictment is based primarily on

section 18, title 2, of the National Prohibition Act (41 Stat. at Large, p. 313), which reads as follows : “See. 18. It shall be unlawful to advertise, manufacture, sell or possess for sale any utensil, contrivance, machine, preparation, compound, tablet, substance, formula, direction, or recipe advertised, designed, or intended for use in the unlawful manufacture of intoxicating liquor.” Two questions are presented:

(1) Was there evidence to warrant the submission of the case to the jury? and (2) does the statute, when properly construed, require proof that both the buyer and seller intended the still should be used for the unlawful manufacture of liquor, or is the requirement of the statute satisfied on proof that the

article was designed for such use and that the seller in making the sale intended it should.be so used? We think the intention referred to in the statute (section 18) is that of the seller alone. It is his act which is made lawful or unlawful, depending upon his intention in regard to the use to be made of the

article sold, provided the

article is designed to carry out that purpose. The Prohibition Act (title 2, § 3) makes the manufacture of intoxicating liquor for beverage purposes, or for nonbeverage and sacramental purposes without a permit, unlawful. And the evidence was that the three-gallon still sold by the defendants was not only designed for use in the manufacture of intoxicating liquors, but that it was the intention of the seller that it should be used in the manufacture of such liquor for beverage purposes. In each case the judgment of the District Court is affirmed. <§E5>For other cases see same topic & KEY-NUMBER in all Key-Numbered Digests & Indexes