LA PAGE v. UNITED STATES, 146 F.2d 536
Opinion
STONE, Circuit Judge. This is an appeal from a conviction for violation of the White Slave Traffic Act, 18 U.S.C.A. § 397 et seq. Appellant urges here three claimed errors:
(1) Improper restriction of cross-examination of a witness; (2) error in the charge to the jury, and (3) insufficiency of the evidence to support the crime set forth in the indictment. We have examined the points as to restriction of cross-examination and as to the charge to the jury and find no merit in either. The serious matter is the sufficiency of the evidence to sustain the crime charged in the indictment. The indictment is in one count under
Section 2 of the Act, 36 Stat. 825, U.S.C.A.
Title 18, § 398, and in the words of that section, charges that appellant “did cause to be transported and aid and assist in obtaining transportation in interstate commerce” of Dora Thomas “for the purpose of prostitution, debauchery, and other immoral purposes.” The evidence established that Dora Thomas (who was an inmate of a house of prostitution operated by appellant at Fargo, North Dakota) had gone to Minneapolis, Minnesota, for a vacation; that appellant telephoned her, one evening, to return as “one of her girls was leaving” and she would be expected early next morning; that it was understood by both women that Dora Thomas would return to Fargo next day by train; and that she did so return.
Baldly, the evidence is that Dora Thomas made this interstate journey at her own expense because of appellant’s telephone request and that both women understood the immoral purpose for which the trip was to be taken. Since there was no evidence that appellant gave any aid or assistance in obtaining the transportation, the sufficiency of the proof depends upon whether it shows that appellant “did cause [Dora Thomas] to be transported” (italics added) within the meaning of
section 2 of the Act. Appellant contends that where, as here, the only act of accused is that of persuading or inducing an interstate trip by common carrier for immoral purposes, such act is not causing such trip within the meaning of
section 2 but is, if any crime, the one stated in
section 3 of the Act, U.S.C.A. Title 18, § 399. The pertinent language in the two sections is :
Section 2. “Any person who shall knowingly * * * cause to be transported * * * in interstate * * * commerce * * * any woman or girl for the purpose of prostitution”; and
section 3, “Any person who shall knowingly persuade, induce * * * any woman or girl to go from one place to another in interstate * * * commerce * * * for the purpose of prostitution.” Since, generally speaking, “ ‘cause’ is a word of very broad import” (United States v. Kenofskey, 243 U.S. 440, 443, 37 S.Ct. 438, 439, 61 L.Ed. 836) and since to “persuade” or to “induce” might very well come within a broad definition of “cause”, the contention is really that “cause” as-.used in
section 2 is limited by exclusion of the means of bringing about specifically set forth in
section 3. In construing these provisions of the two sections, we start with the rules that a statute should be construed so as to give effect to all of its language and that a broad statutory provision will not apply to a matter specifically dealt with in another part of the same Act. Also, it has been determined that the two sections cover separate crimes. One distinction between the two sections has, under some facts, been based upon the necessity of use of a common carrier in
section 3, § 399, U.S.C.A., Title 18, while no such necessity exists in
section 2, § 398, U.S.C.A. Title 18 (Coltabellotta v. United States, 2 Cir., 45 F.2d 117, 119; Blain v. United States, 8 Cir., 22 F.2d 393, 395) but the sections are distinct also irrespective of the common carrier feature and this distinction is between “causing to be transported”, etc., under
section 2, and “persuading, inducing” etc., to be transported under
section 3 (see the Kavalin and Roark cases in note 5). The only way to make that distinction effective and to preserve any effect to this part of
section 3 is to eliminate as causes for transportation under
section 2 the kinds of causation covered in
section 3 by the expressions “persuade, induce, entice, or coerce.” Appellee relies on decisions by this Court as follows: Schrader v. United States, 8 Cir., 94 F.2d 926; Gillenwaters v. Biddle, 8 Cir., 18 F.2d 206; Carey v. United States, 8 Cir., 265 F. 515, and Huffman v. United States, 8 Cir., 259 F. 35. The Schrader case conviction was sustained solely by an application of the “aiding and abetting” statute (Title 18 U.S.C.A. § 550). We need not determine whether that decision should be followed since the fact situation here does not admit of application of
section 550 for the reason that appellant here was the only person involved in this unlawful transportation. However, it is not amiss to state that the effect of
section 399 upon application of
section 550 or upon
section 398 was not brought to our attention or considered in the Schrader case. The Carey case was a general sentence of three months on four counts of indictment —two counts were for furnishing transportation on two trips and the other two counts for “persuading” the victim to make these trips. While the judgment was affirmed, there was no consideration of the point involved here. The Huffman case was conviction on count one and acquittal by verdict on counts two, three and four of an indictment. Count one was for causing a woman to be transported on a trip under
section 2; the second count was identical covering a different trip; count three was for persuading, inducing and enticing (under
section 3) the same woman on the first trip; and count four was identical covering the other trip. A point presented and determined was whether the acquittal on counts two, three and four was inconsistent with the conviction on count one. The judgment was affirmed.
The ground for affirmance is not as distinctly stated as might be (see pages 40-42 of 259 F.) but may fairly be said to be that the several counts pleaded the same transaction in different manner or means of its commission so as “to avoid at the trial an acquittal by reason of any unforeseen lack of harmony between the allegations and the proofs” (page 40 of 259 F.). Also, reliance is placed, by appellee, on Johnson v. United States, 7 Cir., 215 F. 679, L.R.A. 1915A, 862, but this case is not pertinent. The only one of the above cases which bears upon the point before us is the Huffman case.
If that case is to be understood as holding that to “induce,” etc., transportation under
section 3 is within to “cause” to be transported under
section 2, then the authority of that case is materially weakened, if not destroyed, by our later case of Roark v. United States, 8 Cir., 17 F.2d 570, 573, 51 A.L.R. 870. We think the Huffman case should no longer be followed to the effect that to “induce,” etc., under
section 3 is to “cause” under
section 2. Where the accused does no more to “cause”, i. e., to bring about, the transportation than is shown here, the crime is a violation of
section 3 for persuading or inducing and is not a violation of
section 2 for causing unlawful transportation. The test of difference in similar crimes is that there must be a difference in the evidence necessary to establish the particular crime from that required to establish the other crime. Blockburger v. United States, 284 U.S. 299, 304, 52 S.Ct. 180, 86 L.Ed. 306; Gillenwaters v. Biddle, 8 Cir., 18 F.2d 206, 208. Here all of the essential evidence is necessary to establish a crime under
section 3 and there is no further evidence. In short, if this evidence establishes also a crime under
section 2, it must follow that any evidence sufficient to prove a crime under
section 3 is likewise sufficient to prove a crime under
section 2. Since
section 3 is of similar and of narrower application than
section 2, the inevitable result is that all meaning of
section 3 is included in
section 2 and
section 3 states no crime not included in
section 2. This is to strike out
section 3 and give it no effect whatever. We think it is not our province thus to nullify a portion of
an Act, by statutory construction, when it is possible to reconcile the two sections giving each a separate meaning and effect and thereby preserve both sections of the Act In view of our foregoing determination, it is not necessary to examine the further contention of appellant that the judgment should be reversed under authority of Mortensen v. United States, 322 U.S. 369, 64 S.Ct. 1037. The judgment is reversed and the case remanded with directions to enter judgment of acquittal.
Webster’s New International Dictionary, 2nd ed., defines the verb “cause” as being “to be the cause or occasion of; to effect as an agent; to bring about; to bring into existence; to make.” Compare judicially determined meanings in various legal situations as shown in 6 Words and Phrases, Permanent Edition, p. 341 et seq.
Webster’s New International Dictionary, 2nd ed., defines the verbs “induce” and “persuade” as follows: induce is “to lead on; to influence; to prevail on; to move by persuasion or influence”; persuade is “1. to induce (one) by argument, entreaty, or expostulation into a determination, decision, conclusion, belief, or the like; to win over by an appeal to one’s reason and feelings, as into doing or believing something; to bring (oneself or another) to belief, certainty, or conviction; to argue into an opinion or procedure; as, he persuades his friend to study law, that a doctrine is erroneous, into paying his debts, or by many arguments; to persuade oneself that all is well; 2. to use persuasion upon; to plead with; urge; 3. * * * to bring about, by argument and persuasion, the doing, practicing, or believing of; to commend, recommend, counsel, or advise (something to be done or proposed for belief).” Compare legal
definitions in 21 Words and Phrases, Permanent Edition, p. 220 and pocket part and 32 Words and Phrases, Permanent Edition, p. 463 and pocket part. In Ex parte Public National Bank of New York, 278 U.S. 101, 104, 49 S.Ct. 43, 44, 73 L.Ed. 202, is stated; “No rule of statutory construction has been more definitely stated or more often repeated than the cardinal rule that ‘significance and effect shall, if possible, bo accorded to every word.
As early as in Bacon’s Abridgment, § 2, it was said that “a statute ought, upon the whole, to be so construed that, if it can be prevented, no clause, sentence, or word shall be superfluous, void, or insignificant.” ’ Washington Market Co. v. Hoffman, 101 U.S. 112, 115, 25 L.Ed. 782.” D. Ginsberg & Sons Inc., v. Popkin, 285 U.S. 204, 208, 52 S.Ct. 322, 76 L.Ed. 704; Peck v. Jenness, 7 How. 612, 622, 12 L.Ed. 841. United States v. Saledonis, 2 Cir., 93 F.2d 302, 303, 304; Kavalin v. White, 10 Cir., 44 F.2d 49, 51; Roark v. United States, 8 Cir., 17 F.2d 570, 573, 51 A. L.R. 870; and see United States v.
Barton, 2 Cir., 134 F.2d 484. Compare Gebardi v. United States, 287 U.S. 112, 123, 53 S.Ct. 35, 77 L.Ed. 206, 84 A.L.R. 370. For cases with somewhat similar fact situations where court held violation of
section 399 see Blackstock v. United States, 8 Cir., 261 E. 150, certiorari denied 254 U.S. 634, 41 S.Ct. 8, 65 L.Ed. 449; Gillette v. United States, 8 Cir., 236 F. 215; United States v. Barton, 2 Cir., 134 F.2d 484; Simpson v. United States, 9 Cir., 245 F. 278, 280.
Loading document…