Andranik KARABAJAKYAN, a former parolee on behalf of himself and a class of similarly situated persons; Gary Beltran, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. Arnold SCHWARZENEGGER, Governor of California, in his individual capacity; Gray Davis, Former Governor of California in his individual capacity; Roderick Hickman, Former Secretary of the California Youth and Adult Correctional Agency, and CDCR, in his official capacity; Robert Presley, Former Secretary of the California Youth and Adult Correctional Agency, in his individual capacity; Margarita Perez, Former Chairperson of the California Board of Prison Terms, in her individual capacity; Carol Daly, Former Chairperson of the California Board of Prison Terms, in her individual capacity; Fernando Perez, Deputy Commissioner of the California Board of Prison Terms, in his individual capacity; Thomas Wadkins, Deputy Commissioner of the California Board of Prison Terms, in his individual capacity; John Iniguez, Associate Chief Deputy Commissioner of the California Board of Prison Terms and BPH, Head of the Office of Policy and Appeals, in his individual capacity; John Doe 1 or Jane Roe 1, Deputy Commissioner Assigned to the Office of Policy and Appeals whose true name is currently unknown, in his or her individual capacity; Sylvia Labare, Paralegal or Related Aide in the Board of Prison Terms Office of Policy and Appeals in her individual capacity; Christian Becker, Paralegal or Related Aide in the Board of Prison Terms Office of Policy and Appeals in her individual capacity; Melvin E. Hunter, Executive Director Atascadero State Hospital, in his individual capacity, Defendants-Appellees, 377 F. App'x 647